Reviews for Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Elizabethtown, PA

Some Rita?s have weak flavor mixes, mostly ice, but this place never disappoints! Strong flavor, fresh fruit taste! At our last... visit, as we walked up to place our order, we found out Strawberry had run out. But the man immediately offered to make a freshbatch if we were willing to wait 10 minutes, even though it was getting toward the end of the night. We were very impressed andvery grateful! Gracious and kind people run this Rita?s, can?t recommend enough! Read more

Great location. Staff are always friendly. Plus there is a stream that runs by, so you always get to see the ducks. Bring some... corn! Read more

The new owners are really nice, such a great spot to bring the family. The pretzels are really good aswell

Definitely one of the nicer Rita?s in the area. Treats are always delicious. Staff is friendly as well are the owners. They... clean the outside tables each night as well as clean up any trash outside. Read more

the young woman who took my order was eager to give me exactly what I wanted, asking questions to make sure she got it right. ... my Sunday using a twist of vanilla/chocolate soft serve with peanut butter on top with about 7 cherries. was delicious the softserve was creamy with no ice crystals. I recommend Rita's to all. Read more

Nice staff and fast service. I was home visiting PA for the first time in 7 years and just had to stop and get some Rita's! Very... clean outside with lots of places to sit. Delicious ice and custard as always! Just as good as I remembered. Read more

Love going here with my wife and kids. They always get a huge smile on their faces and enjoy going. I personally enjoy the fact... they have more then just straight up ice they have a ton of custard items. Read more

I wanted to order a peanut butter milkshake from the Elizabethtown Rita?s. But I was told they don?t have peanut butter... milkshakes when I clearly got one the other day. Their sign has milkshake with all the flavours and peanut butter was one ofthose flavours. I am not happy and I will drive to the amount Joy Rita?s to get what I want. Read more