Reviews for Otto's Restaurant in Elkhart Lake, WI
The food is really good and so was the service. The only drawback for me is no bread or complimentary appetizers are available.
My husband and I went to dinner on a Friday night for fish frys. The beer battered cod was good. French fries were also good.... Nothing special. Coleslaw was a sweet and sour - not our style. My husband had the perch. It was fairly flavorless. His potatoalso seemed like it was from the day before. Service and atmosphere were great though! Food could use some work. Read more
Waited 45 minutes. Canceled my pizza. Other 3 pizzas were not good. Kids each ate 1/2 slice, wife and daughter 1 bite. Waste of... $80 Read more
This restaurant was really not great. We stayed the weekend at the ostoff and couldn't get it to its other restaurant any of... the evenings. We were tired last night so rather than heading into town we decided to try Otto's.....the selection was poorwith really just pizza and burgers taking up the bulk of the menu. The kids menu was ok featuring the usual suspects you see onall kids menus. Would I come back - probably not. Read more
My wife and I were looking forward to going out for our anniversary but going to Otto?s was a mistake. The baked cod was very... underwhelming. It had no flavor and was just not well prepared. My wife and I agreed that we could of ate way better makingit at home ourselves. Read more
Was staying nearby for the Elkhart Triathlon and had to get a local fish fry. Not only did Otto?s Restaurant have a spectacular... Perch Fish Fry, the Black Cherry Old Fashion was also delicious. Server ?Peyton? was very friendly and I would recommend her asyour server! Read more
Food wasn't spectacular. Fish fry on par with every other tavern Friday fish fry in Wisconsin. Definitely not the dining... experience expected from a resort like the Osthoff. 4 stars only because of excellent service from staff. Food was 3 star only Read more
Please. Listen to the bad reviews. I promise, I usually don't and wish I had! Quite possibly the WORST service I've ever... encountered. Our waitress never checked on us, never once. Not water or a drink or how is your food (that took an insane amountof time). The bartender- equally awful. Never. Ever. Ever. Again. Never Read more