Reviews for Five Star Pizza in St. Augustine, FL

5 Star Pizza was excellent. Delivered to our hotel. Service and driver was awesome. Food was still warm. Remembered plates and... napkins. Pizza and wings were delicious. Price was perfect. Thank you. We will remember you for our next visit to St. Augustine. Read more

We love eating at local "hole in the wall" places. They offer fast delivery but we ordered pick up and out hotel was literally... 0.3 miles and they are not kidding about being fast. The pizzas are huge and extremely good! The staff were nice too! Definitelyrecommend! Read more

Very disappointed! Usually enjoy their pizza. This was supposed to be a pepperoni powerhouse. Got a dried out overcooked... plain pizza. Gonna have to take a break and find somewhere else for our weekly pizza night. Read more

We love 5 star pizza ???? so greatful for dinner tonight. Thank you to the amazing staff and team that always delivers ????.... Yall deserve a raise ?? Pizza was perfecto and the whole fam was full and happy . P.s. thank you for also still giving out goodcoupons. We love yall ???? #5starfoeve' Read more

Never disappointed with our pizza but this time they went above and beyond. We love the Everything minus the jalapeno of course.... Well done with extra sauce. This time they cut it cross wise instead of traditional. BRILLIANT!!! So awesome ???? Whoever madethat decision, brilliant!! Read more

THE BEST PIZZA IN ST AuGUSTINE!! We had 7 people to feed and ordered a 24 inch pizza and didn?t have faith that it would be... enough. When I say it was enough? IT WAS ENOUGH!!! It was also delicious! The garlic butter!!! Chef kiss!!! All 7 of us ate andstill had a good bit left. Also the delivery did not take long at all. Read more

After an agonizing 10 hour drive? To begin our Saint Augustine vacation. We checked into the Fairfield Inn & Suites. My husband,... daughter and I were starved?Pizza!! #1 go to ? We called Dominos and they were super busy and recommended Five Star Pizza. (shocked at the humbling and customer service) My husband spoke with an employee from Five Star and was immediately impressedwith his exemplary customer service skills and positive attitude. We ordered and they even brought the food to our room!!Impeccable service!! Delicious food!! Highly recommend. They even gave us paper plates to use. !! A+++ Read more

My wife and I customized & ordered a large 16? pizza online. When picking up our pizza we were greeted with outstanding customer... service. My pizza was ready & waiting for me within the 10min it took for me to come pick it up & we were offered plates,napkins, & spices free of charge! Read more