Reviews for Peace Pie in St. Augustine, FL
Pre made ice cream sandwiches placed in frozen refrigerator. Shake was small and tasted like water, cream and sugar. $9 for a... small shake!! No whipped cream! McDonald?s makes better shakes. Read more
Ice cream seamed store bought. Cookies are crispy but also frozen rock and made it very hard to enjoy. Staff annoyed to be... there at 6pm. Probably will not return. Read more
Amazing flavors. Fresh ice cream with generous portion on crispy cookies. An absolute must in St Augustine !!
We had a good ice cream sandwich here. It was expensive. If it was layered with pie filling, it sure didn't look like it...but... it was good on a hot day. Had to eat it outside because someone was smoking pot in the back and the store reeeked of it. Read more
The ice cream sandwiches were amazing! I got the peanut butter cookie dough. My husband got the peaches and cream.....the size... of those sandwiches were great for the price Read more
Awesome little place on a side street of downtown St. Augustine. They have GF and vegan options available. Wide range of flavors... to choose from. Friendly service. The Gf sandwich had a harder texture and was difficult to bite into but had good flavor. Wewill visit again. Read more
Y'all. These cookie sandwiches are heaven. If you're in town, do yourself a favor and grab a sandwich from the walk up window,... and enjoy it on a cute walk around the square. There are SO many flavors. The sandwiches are big. The ice cream is so tasty, andso cold, it didn't melt in my hand before I could eat it. The good: everything. The neutral: the cookies are hard, not soft. Butthey are so good and not too hard to eat. The bad: there's probably twice as much ice cream as you need, but it's worth it. Theytake cards, they have little boxes. They have different little pie shots, and you can even buy the cookies. Read more
The girl working there was awesome and super friendly. The ice cream sandwiches were however just ok. I had the peanut butter... and I could barely tell if it was supposed to be that. We also had the pecan one which was also ok. The sandwiches arepre-packaged and we're hard to eat since they were so hard. Read more