Reviews for St. Augie's Pizza in St. Augustine, FL
Best place in St. Augustine for pizza. Great grandma pizza(picture)
I ordered a pizza, mozzarella sticks, and cheese bread from here on 10/21/22, It?s definitely not Papa John?s or Dominos... Quality, but it?s not great either. Pizza was bathed in grease. I?d give it a 5/10. Mozzarella sticks were solid, 7/10. CheeseBread was honestly embarrassing. 1/10. Imagine a roll with a piece of cheese melted on it. Not the worst place, but I will nottry again. :) Read more
It's a cute cozy authentic Pizza place. It's local family owned restaurant here in St Augustine. We had Pizza and meatballs... on Stick. It was delicious. The service was friendly. The price was good. Only thing is the soda is in can or bottle. Norefillable drinks. The place and bathroom was clean. Mostly they have a lot pick ups or take away. ... We had a amazing dinner. ... Read more
The service was quick and friendly. I feel like there is a lot of potential here. There was a ton of chicken on my chicken bacon... ranch pizza and I believe that sapped the moisture from the pizza. It was pretty dry and much better when dipped in sauce. Thesize of the pizza and the value was great, I think with another visit this may be a higher ranking. Unfortunately with so manychoices in a short vacation that second trip will most likely not happen. Read more
So my first time eating Saint Augustine pizza place I did not enjoy it. My pizza was burnt my wings were over cooked. I asked... for extra cheese and there was barely any cheese. Never going back. Pizza Time is the best pizza so far I have tasted here inFlorida. Read more
We order the grandmas pie from here frequently (it?s hands down the best pizza I?ve had in the area). And tonight they wrote a... little message in the box that really made our night. Kudos to the crew thanks for making a customer feel special and reallyjust going above and beyond in terms of great customer service. Read more
Hands down this place has the most delicious and authentic slice of NY style pizza you will find in the state of Florida. I?ve... been eating pizza from this family from 20+ years, back when they were based in NY. Today we made a 4 hour drive to St. Augie?sjust to enjoy a slice and some garlic knots. If you?re in the area, make sure you stop here. You will not regret it. Thestaff is friendly and the menu offers plenty of pizza as well as a plethora of other options. St. Augie?s has something foreveryone. Read more
The MOST authentic New York pizza I?ve ever had. The crust is PERFECT, the quality and consistency of the sauce is amazing. The... cheese that they use is incredible. I am in saint Augustine about once every 3 months I will never be back without eating here.100% my favorite pizza place in world! Read more