Reviews for Tony And Nick's Italian Kitchen in Ellenville, NY
One of the VERY few non vegan places I've been with a vegan menu that doesn't feel like an afterthought. I could get an... appetizer, soup, salad, entree, or pizza if I wanted. We got the sweet potato truffle pizza off of the vegan menu and it wasAMAZING. The onion soup was great too. Our non vegan family we went with loved their food as well. Our takeout we ordered thenext time was just as great. We will definitely be back. Read more
A local gem in upstate NY for great Italian food and good wine selection. One of the best Eggplant Parm I have ever had and the... vegan pizza (pizza oven not ready til noon) was great. Yes, FYI they have a Vegan menu. The server was super friendly and veryknowledgeable. Generous serving sizes if you want to share and have leftovers. Read more
Not quite 4 stars, but almost so I'm rounding up. This place has a nice atmosphere but the staff ranges from being very pleasant... and inexperienced to some having an attitude. The main course, Chicken Parmesan, was a bit of a disappointment. Not bad, but alittle tough and their sauce is a little thinner than I like, but not anything to complain about. They served delicious breadwith olive oil along with our drinks. The drink was generously sized. We had lemon sorbet for dessert which comes frozen in alemon - that was quite good. I can't say anything bad about this place, but nothing really stood out either. It's probably oneof the best restaurants in town if you are going to Shadowlands theater, and it's right across the street. Read more
The food here is delicious and the staff is very gracious and friendly .
My Wife and I had an amazing experience at Tony and Nick's. We went for lunch on a Friday afternoon and will definitely be back.... What was more impressive than their delicious food, was their obvious obsession and dedication to hospitality. Havingexperienced other restaurants in the area, they clearly know how to care for their guests. I would highly recommend this placeover anything in the immediate vicinity. Read more
Disappointing night out, we waited for over an hour for our entrees despite being one of only three tables. We were going to see... a movie after so I had to go find a waiter who brushed me off before I could finally get someone to pack it up straight from thekitchen. I was patient with waiting until they were rude with me trying to ask for help. My husband had paced his drink to havesome with food but had to abandon a half full cocktail. They charged us full price for a meal we didn't get to eat (fine), andthe waitress stood over me while I was writing in the tip (20% bc I've worked service) but that was the most attentive either ofthem were all night. The food we did get (a no prep needed app) was good but definitely not worth the wait Read more
Very satisfied with our first time here. The staff was very friendly and courteous. Food was great and entree portions are... generous. Highly recommend the lobster ravioli and chicken and eggplant parm! Read more
Used to eat here sometimes a few years ago. They always had decent food and slow, so-so service but decided to try them again... recently. The restaurant was more than half empty but it took 10 minutes to get water and when we tried to order drinks we weretold we needed to speak to our waitress. After another five minutes without seeing said waitress, or being acknowledged at all,and seeing other patrons looking around, we bolted. Ordered BBQ to go from the Outpost and it was ready by the time we got there10 minutes later. I have never walked out of a restaurant before but it was the right move in this case. Read more