Reviews for Santino's Pizza Shack in Elma, NY
Pizza wasn't very good and the service was a little lacking. 1st time ever being here but probably wouldn't go back.
The steamed clams and fries were good. The pizza was raw dough like an inch in away from the edges but I brought it home and... cooked it in the oven. As it being the second day open, they didn't have clams casino :(. Maybe I'll be back.. Read more
Hamburger taste like McDonald?s meat Fries hard and you have to ask for Togo silverware and condiments Update great service,... timely manner 4 stars ???? Read more
I liked it ,the food was good I just think beer could come down a bit in price, something like senior specials when you open on... fridays,lol we were there from noon till 4 it was nice catching up with Zoe. I miss the people but that's what happens when youget old. We will come back hope to see you sometime.. Don't go out much when it's late. Read more
I've been getting their pizza on and off since 1976, no joke, I grew up on Bowen Road. Best cheese and pepperoni pizza in WNY... and it's still costs around $20.00 - love the heavy amount of cheese and classic sauce...it hasn't changed at all. Thank youSandy! Read more
Great pizza and service!!! Our pizza and wings were done on time. The pizza was very good and had lots of pepperoni !!!????The... wings were also very good!!! Very meaty. We tried the mild Buffalo sauce and it was perfect!!! This was our first time tryingSantino?s, and we will be back!!! They also have takeout for beer!!! ???? another plus!!! Read more
Great little place. Doesn't look like much from the outside, but don't pass it by. You'll be glad you stopped!
Just moved close, used to go here all the time when I lived on Bowen Road. The dough is RAW, trying to save it by putting in... oven , wings were good. Disappointed not the same Pizza Read more