Reviews for Paesano's Pizza & Subs in Elmira, NY
Pretty disappointing. Ordered a MEDIUM veggie and the total came to $22 ?! a lot for a medium pizza. It was missing ingredients.... I tried calling them 4 times upon realization and they wouldn?t answer. They gave me a hard time the next day about making areplacement even though they offered. If you don't have all of the ingredients, why would you be okay with charging full priceor selling it at all? It isn't the customer's fault you don't have the ingredients and you should be upfront about it to beginwith. Customer service is a big part of running a business and they lack it. Read more
Me and my friend walked in there and the place was disgusting shoes on the counter the floor is disgusting hand towels on the... floor next to where they keep the soda we walked right back out no wonder why everyone gets sick Read more
Amazing food and service!!!!!
Ordered 2 x-large pizzas 2 orders of wings and 2 orders of mozzarella sticks and all of it was barely edible and cold the pizzas... and mozzarella sticks weren't cooked fully one of the mozzarella sticks came with cocktail sauce instead of marinara sauce. Thewings were the only thing cooked but they had no flavor it was like I was eating baked chicken. On top of all of that everyonein the house ended up waking up and puking at 2 or 3 in the morning. To sum everything up the food was honestly barely edibleand got us all sick I do not recommend ordering here and I will not be ordering here again. Read more
Grew up in Elmira I always thought pudgies was the best pizza I can't wait to get back home to get pudgies Pizza but sorry... pudgies loses your pizza is the best taste like New York City big nice slices great cheesesteaks excellent job Read more
Picked up x-lg pizza in the middle of the time window.6 blocks later at home found the pizza to be luke warm yet the crust was... burned but not hot. Crust was so thin we had to use fork to eat it. Second bad experience at Paesanos And is also our last. Read more
Found my "no onions" chefs salad with a layer of onions under the meat. Raw onions don't like me.Raw dough in my son's... stromboli . Crispy fries mushy. Pizza a bit under baked. $50+ order Read more
Great pizza and strombolis. Fast and friendly service!