Reviews for Black River Tavern in Elyria, OH
We were a big group, about 38 people, but with reservations, I would think there could have been better staffing. ( I get the... staffing issues of 2022) Our servers were great, but only 2 was pushing it, as it meant serving was sporadic and food was justwarm. Food was good despite the temp. The venue is gorgeous and quaint where our dinner was held. Loved the golf simulators. Read more
Solid 4.0. We had the huge portion - Lobster Roll/ Onion Rings and the 3 Chicken Tacos. The lobster roll was large and... filling, needed a bit more lobster. Flavor was dulled by other ingredients. Onion rings were crispy and breaded properly. Thechicken tacos were excellent. We also had the pretzels ( 3 pretzels seems a little skimpy ) the cheese dip Was excellent Wewrapped up with 2 fried chicken sandwiches and their Curley steak fries. The kids loved this. This was our second visit. Themenu is big enough the I will return for third meal. Also FYI , Pizza looked great. Read more
Great food, really nice ambiance. Awesome wood wall was behind us while we ate. Our server was great and very attentive.
Our lunch for four was excellent. We sat outside, in the shade, on a beautiful day. The waitress was very attentive,... personable, but not bothersome. The pizza crust was enhanced with a green herb which made it delicious. The club sandwich onsourdough was enormous and was filled with lots of turkey and bacon. The grilled chicken sandwich was huge, tasty, but wasslippery and drippy with the pepper ranch sauce. The least favorite was the crab roll sandwich. Our expectations fellshort. There is a new menu coming out after Labor Day, so it should be interesting to view. We will definitely return to thisbeautiful restaurant. Read more
The brussel sprouts were so good followed by the lobster and crab roll. Everything was absolutely delicious. The staff was... friendly and knowledgeable. Will be back. Read more
Had a party of 12+ today. Was seated in kind of a private area. Every single table in there was covered in food and syrup, they... didn’t clean them. The food was average at best and took an hour and a half. The drinks took 15 minutes to get to us. Mycoffee was cold. The kettle chips were basically fried grease skins with no flavor or seasoning or salt. Pretty disappointedbecause I’ve been here before and loved it. The price of the food for the taste was outrageous. Go to McDonald’s next time. Read more
The New menu is amazing. This is a place you need to try. Pretty good lunch and an updated dinner menu with a touch of... everything! I'll be making another dinner reservation soon! Read more
We've hosted two Secret Society Comedy shows at Black River Tavern, and the staff was incredibly kind and accommodating at both.... The pizzas are great, and the place is the perfect space to host an event. Read more