Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Englishtown, NJ
This place has gone down hill. We order wings first then pizza and a dinner. Wings came out and about 45 minutes later the... waitress comes over and asks what we ate waiting for. She blamed the system for not registering our order?! So we decided not tore order and just left after paying for the wings. Not to mention dirty tables and two hostess standing around doing nothingwhile the place has one waitress running around! Second time we had a bad experience I let the first one slide!! Read more
Had the most delicious margarita pizza! As well as the most friendly, attentive server Rhema! Drinks, food and ambiance were... perfection! We'll be back soon! Read more
Myself and a friend found ourselves in freehold NJ. Passed Anthony's coal fired pizza and decided to stop in for...a sandwich. ... We both ordered a steak and cheese with different toppings and OMG this was the best steak and cheese I've ever had! My buddyDan said the same about his. Highly recommend if you're in the area. It's not super fast but also not too slow. But well worththe stop. Read more
We ordered a pizza via Uber eats giving this place a try. Unfortunately our experience was very disappointing. Pizza arrived... VERY COLD and was missing some toppings. Not worth the $26 we paid. There are better places out there for half the price !!!!!! Read more
What once was is no longer. Salad , wings and pizza where good. The floors are slippery and dirty. The table didn’t seem... cleaned it may or may not have been. Most of all my server was a young man with no manners , spoke like he was on the street,paid no mind to his tables. We Waited 25 minutes for a salad while he socialized with the pizza makers, when he brought thesalad and forgot to bring the cheese. I had to get up and ask for it.. We asked for sugar for the ice tea and salt on the tablehe never brought it. I had to physically get up and walk to another table to get them. Then brought the wings and pizza at thesame time almost 40 minutes later. There was clearly no management there just bunch kids doing their thing. When it was timeto pay the bill he circled around like a hungry shark. I was not going to leave a tip but was encourage not to do so , so I’msure he’s wondering why I only left him $ 5.00 for on a $62 bill. Someone there needs to wake up. I was not the onlycustomer visibly annoyed. One very important thing keep your fingers out of your mouth while taking peoples dinner orders !! Saturday night 9/10 7 pm Read more
I called and ordered at 4:54 an margarita pizza. I got it at 4:52pm a lady came out saying it was a miscommunication where?... don’t know. I don’t think i’m going to order ever again if i’m going to wait 1 hour for a pizza! Also I asked for themanager and he never came out! bad vibes!!!!! Read more
Service and ambiance were pretty nice. However, the food was nothing big and way too overpriced and was raw. The garlic knots... were extremely chewy on the inside dough and the eggplant pizza’s dough was uncooked and soft and cold. Not coming back. Read more
This place is awesome! Our waitress Daniella ( I hope I spelled it right) was extremely helpful. She gave us great... recommendations: The roasted wings was delicious but the dry rub#2 was a delightful, flavorful surprise-absolutely tasty. Themanager was so gracious he gave me a sample of the rub. The pizza was thin crust and flavorful- like the kind I grew up in NewYork. If you are shopping in the area treat yourself to Anthony's you will not be disappointed. Read more