Reviews for The Pickled Herring in Englishtown, NJ

Corned Beef and Pastrami combo sandwich was excellent, piled high, warmed to the perfect eating temperature, with cole slaw and... thousand island dressing. Try the house, round cut potato fries, better than the frozen standard. Wide range of deli availablefor take out or catering. Go with friends or family, you'll have a great time. Read more

We went for dinner this past Saturday night and could not have been more thrilled with the entire experience. The service was... great (thank you, Linda), the restaurant was clean and smelled delicious, and the food was outstanding. The pickles were freshand had the perfect snap; the pastrami was tasty, juicy, lean and had not a hint of gristle, and the rye bread was sheerperfection. Oh, and the potato pancake was simply divine - golden and warm on the inside, crunchy and hot on the outside. Theportions were generous (we both took food home), too. Special shout-out to Mindy for all she did/does - she made us feel likemishpuchah (family). We can't want to go back (and we will, soon)! Read more

Been coming here since working in the plaza 4 years ago (and still come even though I don?t work there anymore) definitely on... the pricier side (most expensive lox bagel I?ll ever eat) but the food is great and they give you a lot of jt. Staff makes youfeel welcome as well. Place gets busy on Sundays and you can tell they have a lot of regulars who come throughout the week Read more

Found this place by accident on my way to hobby lobby. What a treasure. I grew up near some of the most famous Jewish delis in... NY and haven't had it in so long. I was impressed and so thrilled to have found it. I will be back, many more times. We had aRuben, pastrami sandwich, stuffed cabbage, potato pancakes. My only suggestion is more onion in the potato pancakes buteverything else was delicious. Read more

Matzo Ball was light and fluffy with the taste of comfort! This is not your diner matzo softball. And let?s talk about the... Pastrami?. Lean, no gnarly gristle but kept all the flavor. Rye bread was fresh and the slaw was a health slaw. We werecomplimented with a bowl of half sour and full sour pickles that were as you would expect. My son ordered the southwest chickenbut opted to switch to a chicken cutlet instead of the blackened chicken. He said it was a top 10 chicken sandwich. Now, too 10is big for him. I happen to be a chef and we have eaten all over the world. He prides himself on being a cutlet connoisseur.Looking fwd to trying more. Our server was sweet and was very pleasant. Read more

The portions at this Jewish deli were plentiful. Great service. Food was fresh. The only thing was the French fries were either... cooked in older oil or something was not 100%. Other than that, an excellent place to eat. Read more

The Smoky Joe (Belly lox instead of nova) was delicious ! Husband loved the chop liver and pastrami sandwich! Also enjoyed the... Derma?..will be back ???? % Read more

We ordered take out and everything was a ?10?. This is an authentic kosher style deli that reminds me of Brooklyn. We?ve eaten... in and everything was perfect but we?re worried about taking out. No worries necessary because everything was well wrapped, allcondiments and extras were included. The corned beef on club sandwich was delicious and cooked to perfection. The Reuben wasdelicious. The toasted mushroom barley and derma was so delicious as well. Oh and the matzoh ball soup tasted authentic andhomemade. I highly recommend this place and will enjoy being a returning customer. Read more