Reviews for Presque Isle Pizza Restaurant / Connie's Ice Cream in Erie, PA

Staff is great always willing to help.. Personally, I saw 2 of the teen age girls, getting ready to close, when a group of... parents and kids came for ice cream..The girls were Amazing, never complained or had an attitude they cared for the patrons andwaited in case someone needed more. Read more

5 stars for the chicken wings and ranch but 2 stars for the pizza. The pizza was thin and tasteless and the sausage was very... disappointing. Also, someone does not know how to cut a pizza. I had to come home and use my own pizza cutter to cut through it. Read more

Picky picky picky and confused describes me when trying to decide or find vegetarian ice cream. And ice cream for the first time... at this place almost caused me to have to call the fire department from having a mouth orgasm. Their vegetarian ice cream is sogood all I could do is moan and groan after every bite. Didn't care who was around either. I have my taste buds the bestexercise any mouth could have that day. I definitely will be back in body armor and helmet next time. Read more

Great place. My family loved the pizza and I loved the wings. The kids devoured some ice cream when it was all done. Last game... of the season dinner my daughter picked was great!!! Can?t wait to go back. Read more

We just moved to Erie and ordered here our first night. The pizza tasted and had the consistency of a frozen grocery store... pizza. However, I'm giving it 2 stars because the wings were average. We won't be ordering again. Read more

The customer service, I give that 5 stars. Everyone was helpful and friendly. I appreciate that. The wings were delicious.... Taking the rest home to destroy them. 10 wings for 14.99. Although the price was a little higher then my preference, I stillenjoyed them and might get them again. The pizza, personally, not great for me. Everyone liked it enough. Thank you to all thestaff... Read more

They have Homemade Dough, Sauce, and Import their own Banana Peppers from Italy. They're Very Sweet Banana Peppers, not "Hot",... whatsoever. We had ordered their Extra Large Pizza. They called it, "The P". A Pizza w/32 piece's, vs. 16 piece's. They give youa starting point with Pepperoni and Cheese. We added Bacon, Extra Cheese and Banana Peppers. I've never known anyone in Erie,PA., to make "Detroit Style", Pizza's before. They actually make Detroit Style Pizza in all the Pizza's they create. "DetroitStyle" is a combination of 2 Styles of Pizza: 1. Deep Dish Chicago Style Pizza. 2. Thin Extremely Large Crust Brooklyn StylePizza. I knew of and made, one other Style: Thick Extremely Large Crust Brooklyn White Style Pizza. My friend's from Collegewould go to my parents house, yo eat authentic Sicilian Food. They learned these "Styles", and suggested these "Styles of Pizza"to a local pizza shoppe. They actually added their own version to that Style of Pizza. Very few people back in the 1980's, knewhow to make White Pizza Style the original version. Read more

My friend loves their ice cream. The chocolate peanut butter has delicious peanut butter swirls!