Reviews for Pymatuning Pizza in Espyville, PA
First time stoping here! Great service, reasonably priced, fast service. We ate (pizza) out front on the porch while watching... traffic. I would like to note that. Every bite had the toppings that was order and was cooked correctly, golden crust notdoughy.not burnt.not crunchy! Very pleased will be back soon!! Read more
First time ordering from Pymatuning Pizza. The crust was thick enough to hold the toppings but it wasn't all dough like other... shops around. Half the pizza was cooked and the other half was doughy. There wasn't much sauce or flavor. Like banana peppersdidnt have flavor, sausage didn't taste like anything but it was hot. I was very disappointed that the prices online from theirwebsite are not correct. I hope they fix them. It cost $42 from pizza and a salad. Yet they have a Friday special that "cost"$32 that includes Pizza wings breadsticks and a salad. Online it states a 18" pizza starts at $18 and toppings are $1.50 each.They're $2. I don't mind a restaurant upping their price but you should update your menu online. The reviews of this spot varyand I can see why. Perhaps we'll try ordering again and see if it's just an off day. Read more
Pizza is good, but subs are by far the best! I see to many complaints here for some bad days with staffing or equipment failure,... but still worth the wait! The fact your willing to make up for it with a credit or to remake the food is awesome, bad dayshappen! Overall will still be back and continue to recommend! Read more
Really good pizza. It was quick and delicious, made with good ingredients. I really like pan crust, it was thick but not doughy.... Staff was pleasant. I?ll definitely be going back, would like to try their subs. Read more
Updated : I have been back and the pizza was delicious, it has a good taste will stop back again . I talked to the owner and... I'm sorry it took me this long to get back I'm sad to say my first experience here was bad. I went in and ordered, paid ,and said my order would be ready in a half hour . I returned and they never made my pizza, I got my money back , but it was toolate for us to go anywhere else . I hope if I come back it is a better Read more
Fresh ingredients and best pizza I have had in a long time. Can tell it is home made crust. I see comments about the smell... Mine is delicious. Though I know new pans can make a chemical smell never had that issue. Read more
Honestly sadly disappointed. It was our first time ordering from here. We order 2 extra large pepperoni pizza?s. Both our pizzas... were burnt, we only got 2 pieces of pepperoni on each piece of pizza and the pizza was extremely greasy. I hope this was just aone time fluke. Not sure what everyone else?s experiences have been. ???????? Read more
If you like thick, doughy pizza, this is your place. I did order the thin pizza option. But it was pillowy, which is fine, but... wasn?t expected when I thought it was going to be much thinner. Read more