Reviews for Anthony's Pizza & Pasta in Evergreen, CO

The pizza is by far one of the best I?ve tried in Colorado. Juicy and EJ are very friendly, fast and provide top notch service.

i love anthony?s so much now. there was a very clear and positive change in management. the staff makes a very fun environment.... i love going there with my friends. it?s always a such a fun experience. and watching the boys make pizza is so entertaining.they are so good at tgere job. wow! this place is pretty lit on my momma fr fr. we?re at a 100 on my odometer no cap. thisrestaurant is like by far the best one in evg. even if ur not in the mood for pizza go to anthony?s it?ll make you happy. love uguys.???? Read more

Warning!!! For The Price go to dominos, pizza hut, or anywhere else!_! Tried to get a pizza for my birthday and got a pizza... that had to have set for or more than 2+ hours and ordered 1 hour before they closed and got inedible food!!! Ordered, Pickedup, an home in 45 to 50 mins. This is disgraceful. Worked for this company before "covid" an beyond. They have changed fooddistribution an gotten pork sausage not Italian sausage!!! The rest of there toppings are questionable. There sauce has changed.There dough has changed. Cheese everything. No longer authenticate New York style pizza just over priced garbage!!! Also theyhire mostly pot heads, stoners and druggies. So expect your orders to be wrong and not edible. More then half the time. ThisPLACE NEEDS SHUT DOWN!!!... Just give up in this town. The gut wrenching pizza needs to stop...... Will never order hereagain. Carry out or otherwise!!! Read more

Two stars because our order was way off and the gluten free pizza was terrible. The staff DID want to make it right but we just... didn't have the time to wait, maybe next time will be better. Read more

Under new management, the quality of food and customer service hits the mark. Go see for yourself!!

They forget to cook your pizza, you wait 30 minutes longer while your other dinner items get cold, or warm, then they only offer... 20% off. Exactly how the Conifer location operated. The location that?s now closed. Disappointing? **Shared as requested viathe link you provided** Read more

Pizza was undercooked with some ingredients completely raw and the wings were just awful. Store is ran by a bunch of stoned... Highschool kids that sit around and talk to their friends all day. It?s a shame because this franchise has a good reputation forquality food. Read more

This pizza joint SLAPS! A local referred us here and we?re forever grateful. They just get it, ya know? Fresh ingredients w/an... authentic style! Every member of the staff was beyond gracious and the restaurant was clean. Great place to snack n? chill. Read more