Reviews for Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings in Fair Lawn, NJ

Love the wings and pizza, but it didn't travel well. Tried take out for the first time and the food was very dry.

Very good food. Menu has expanded to more options which is a plus. Cesar salad one of the best I have eaten.

Half Margherita, half meatballs ricotta pizza came out perfect this time, not very well done, crust, sauce, meatballs, cheese... delicious Read more

I would give my 4 stars for the Service. Andrea was really good going back-and-forth asking us if everything was good. The food... I would give two stars. We order pizza and garlic knots. Not the best pizza. Read more

I love well done pizza so this place comes in clutch. We had the meatball and ricotta pizza. As far as the food is considered... the place is great Read more

everyone ate the food bc they were hungry and didn’t want to wait another 30 minutes but i called and asked for it to not be... well done because the pizza is always burnt. it was disgusting and i think they poured the buffalo sauce straight in the bowl. Read more

Anthony's is an awesome pizzaria. The cauliflower pizza was indescribably delicious, and it was unlike anything I've ever had on... a pizza before. Wings are also very meaty and have a really nice sweet and spicy combo that isn't too overwhelming; perfectlybalanced. Staff is also very friendly and attentive! Read more

The best pizza in the area, served in a casual atmosphere. Great roasted wings & the rids are worth trying too!