Reviews for Agostino's Restaurant & Bar in Fairview Heights, IL

I’ve been here two times now and both time had absolutely outstanding service. We came in both times right around the time... they would probably be closing, and normally most restaurants are pretty frustrated by that, but the owner and the server wereso warm and welcoming. It’s almost like they treat strangers like family. The food has been incredible both times, everythingfrom the appetizers, to the salad, to the main courses. I got lamb both times and my fiancé the spaghetti. Both superb.There’s not a lot of really nice restaurants without going to St. Louis, this one is worth checking out! Really coolold-school Italian vibe! Read more

Service was great. Food was great, but on the pricey side for the missing 5th star. Great for a fancy date night or anniversary,... but not for standard supper option. Read more

I like what I have ordered. Food and service are good. The place can be updated to match its pricing.

Sarah was our waitress and she was a pleasure! The food was very fresh, hot and delicious! We lived in Northern Italy for years... and this is the REAL thing!! Read more

We had a wonderful evening tonight at Agostino’s. First, Great Service. We had the stuffed mostaccioli w/meat balls, fabulous.... And, the Polo Marsala was excellent. The cocktails, very satisfying. Definitely a formidable alternative to a drive to The Hill. Read more

FOOD WAS AMAZING BUT........ ONCE AGAIN, SERVICE, ORDER(Charged me for chicken, I never got, told him and said they was taking... it off, They Didn't) AND Waiter WAS Below Average. NEVER GOT REFILLS UNTIL WE WAS LEAVING. 3 stars only because Taste Awesome. If they Would Hire some Great Help... Hands Down WOULD BE 5 STAR. BUT SAD SERVICE. 1 WAITER WAS OVERWHELMED AND OWNER TRIED TOHELP. JUST HIRE SOMEONE. PEOPLE WILL TIP GOOD AT A PLACE LIKE THAT IF THEY WOULD JUST GET GREAT SERVICE Read more

I am passing through the area and stopped in as I was staying at a hotel near by. The staff was fantastic and the FOOD was... absolutely delicious! I had a side Ceasar salad, which was huge! I also had the tortellini...it was soooo very good! Idefinitely recommend dining here! Read more

The place looks a little dated and maybe even ratty even but the food was amazing. Big problem they added small shrimp to the... pasta dish that they did not "devein". Small critiques I had a large Italian salad wish it was more than just greens tomatoesand onions but the parmesan and dressing were pretty tasty. The tiramasu was broken up on one end but again tasted amazing, Iassume it just happened when it was cut. Lastly I had a pasta dish with tomatoes shrimp mussels mushrooms and a wine sauce itwas delicious but there was so much sauce they had to wrap my styrofoam to go????. The guy who brought me my food was a littleawkward but very attentive. When he gave me my food he made sure I held it upright so I didn't spill anything and when I askedfor a spoon he basically ran to grab one. I assume this small business was hit by covid and they deserve business Read more