Reviews for Tonys Italians Pizziera and Restaurant in Farmingdale, NJ

I guess it changed ownership. The music was so loud that I thought I was in a nightclub. Gave the waitress my order of a... cheeseburger with yellow American cheese and it came with a melted white cheese. If she had written it down she might havegotten it correct. My lunch partner didn't get what she asked for either. I have been going there for over 25 years, but it'snot the same. Sad. Read more

We walked in and then walked right back out. It was somewhat late, and most of the slices they had in the (non-refrigerated)... showcase looked like they had been sitting there all day. Read more

We've been going here for a few weeks now! Every week! Food is always fresh! Cheesesteak pizza is amazing! White pizza is really... good too Salads are huge! Chicken rolls,sausage rolls are both excellent! Rice balls are a must! Read more

The pizza and Italian wedding soup was amazing. So glad I stopped in while traveling from Georgia. We cannot get pizza like this... where I live. I will be back anytime I am in the area. Read more

I was in the area the other day and was in the mood for pizza. I ordered a large plain pie. It was Sooooo good and tasty, that I... was still licking my lips after eating 3 slices. Lol 5 stars for sure for me. I will definitely be back!! Love yourpizza!!!!?????? Read more

A hidden Jersey Gem! Food is Amazing, portions are plenty, and the staff is great!!

Great local Italian place with a wonderful selection of typical pizza shop fare and sit down Italian entrees. The place is... bumping on the weekend with music and patrons, so be sure to come early or late or prepare to wait. Regardless, it's alwaysservice with a smile here. Definitely worth the stop if you are passing through town. Read more

Excellent pizza, this is the Sicilian pie. Always fresh ingredients. Staff very friendly and pleasant. Haven't eaten at the... indoor dining area but its always busy. Liquor store across the street if you need something to wash it down with. Read more