Reviews for Jersey Mike’s Subs in Farmingdale, NY

The new staff takes almost an hour just to have a small order ready, that was made online. When i came for pick up, they didnt... start on it untill 10 minutes after i got there. Never again, this is the third time it's happened. Read more

Good sliced to order subs. However the inability to customize meats and cheese in the app is a miss. They have turkey and... American Cheese and can get in store but not thru the app. Also standard app pick up time is 45 minutes which is always muchless so the sandwiches can be cold or soggy. Read more

The sandwiches at this fdale location have always been robust compared to other locations. They slice the meats thin which gives... it a good flavor. Manager & staff there are pleasant. Read more

I ordered the club and was supposed to have ham turkey and bacon all I got was ham and cheese and they weren?t busy at all

Customer service is absolutely horrible. Don't even waste your time trying to go here for lunch, they move like sloths. You have... enough time to go to the grocery store and make your own sandwich. Read more

While watching the employee make my sandwich he put a topping on I don't like. Upon questioning him he lies to me and tells me... it was the correct topping. Tried it before I left and sure enough it's wrong. Read more

This is my go to Jersey Mikes since they've opened. I don't live too far and I love their product...but this store has changed.... The quality of service is different. I was in a couple of weeks ago. I app'd the order and when I arrived they were no wherenear ready...though the app said a designated time...I know nothing is perfect but the attitude behind the counter was off.Today I went in to order and there was a employee making a series of sandwiches for an order but the prep counter was a mess.(That order wasn't ready either when the customer arrived)Don't get me wrong their making sandwiches with alot of ingredientsbut you have to tidy up because it really doesn't look appetizing. You don't know how long the work area has been covered withremnants of other sandwiches. Just a tip...try to clean as you go. I'm sure you are short-handed as many companies are. Thisdoesn't sway my loyalty...I'm still going to order from there. Just wanted to share an observation. Keep striving for customerexperience. ?? ?? Read more

Jersey Mikes is decent, and blows nasty Subway away. However, most Long Islanders know deli prices are high, but a good deli... deserves to charge high prices. Therefore, I figured I?d try JM?s. JM has decent sandwich but far more expensive than localdeli. I paid $8 for a mini 1/4 hero roast beef.. wow! Should have been a $5 sandwich. The pic here is of half RB sandwich fromdeli on New Hwy near Smith st. for $7. Worth every penny- tasted awesome. Not often I chose deli over other food places? butJM?s way overpriced and so so food. I do love JM balling up meats to make it appear like you get a good amount?lol Read more