Reviews for Island Fish in Farmingville, NY
I do have to say this is a fish market, but they do serve foods. There is a big selection on the menu and I'm very satisfied... with my lunch . Read more
Absolute amazing find, my only regret is not knowing about them sooner. The prices are unbelievable for the level of quality... and the portions. Super friendly staff. I hope that my family and I are able to keep coming back to them again and again formany years into the future. Read more
Go here. Buy fish. Eat fish. Fresh fish. AMAZING selection, prices and portions. This is our new go to seafood joint!
Wonderful place. I'm just sad I discovered it my last night on vacation! Delicious food, we had shrimp scampi, fish n chips,... fried rock lobster, shrimp candy, everything was delicious. Everything is very fairly priced as well. Everyone was reallyfriendly even though we showed up the last hour before closing. I thought we were somehow back in Iowa bc everyone was so nice!We will absolutely be back next time we're in LI! Read more
This is a little hidden gem, that is always serving fantastic products and customer service?. The staff is very personable and... the food is excellent? I highly recommend Island Fish Read more
Went to this fish market to purchase lobsters and scallops. The wait staff was excellent.! He made AWESOME suggestions! Thanks... for even letting me sample fresh made dry sea scallops!! They were amazing! See you guys soon for more delicious seafood! Hereis a pic of my end RESULT!???????? Read more
This place has the best fresh raw and cooked seafood in the area. Great prices, Great customer service, awesome selection, clean... place and great location. Not hard to miss on the road. Love this place. Come here atleast every other month to get my seafoodfix. Have been open lately with all the new bull going on. As you can see I got snow crab legs and they are surprisingly huge.Better then going to BJs or Sam's. Not that they not good but these are better. See you guys soon. Its almost about that time.Stay safe and wear your mask when going in. Read more
Went in for the 5 for $20 lobster tails which were Tony so of course we upgraded and paid double that price. The deal exists but... not worth it. They do have a descent selection of crab legs, Alaskan king legs and lobster tails so that's a plus Read more