Reviews for Pelletier's Restaurant & Fish Boil in Fish Creek, WI

Breakfast here was excellent. I had an amazing Cherry Muffin. My group throughly enjoyed omlettes. Vintage Door County, WI... decor, ambiance. Very busy on a Fall weekend. Good, prompt service. Cash only. Centrally located to many fun, touriststores. Parking is hard to find. Town of Fish Creek is quaint--a Midwestern, Lake Michigan version of Cape Cod Read more

The boil was an experience to see. I didn't have it, but those in our group enjoyed it. However, the ladies greeting us to take... our order(30min-1hr prior as rules) was rude as very unprofessional. Even after my wife ate, she went back to get a second glassof red wine, and when the lady asked what she had my wife said "red wine" WELL......we DO have 3 red wines so how am I too knowwhich one you had! My wife simple said "tell me the names and I'll know it, that simple." This was a one and done for us. Wewill not go back when in the area. Read more

The food was very good but would have been nice to have the option to pick boneless. Also could have made the entrance process... faster by taking the orders when people make the reservations. Lastly, having umbrellas outside at the tables to block the sunwould have been nice. Read more

This is our first time coming and my wife and I along with our 8 year old granddaughter loved it! We all got the fish boil and... it was fantastic! It was done right and the flavors were spot on. I really enjoyed sitting outside and so close to the boil potthat we could see everything that was done. I will definitely come back when in the area. Read more

Great experience. I was worried I would not really like the fish but it was excellent. Servers were great as well! Highly... recommend Read more

We had the fish boil. It was soooo goood!!!! Well worth it to see the show as well (the fish being cooked), all with an awesome... view of the bluffs of Fish Creek for your background. I don't eat coleslaw but their coleslaw was so good I ended up enjoying itand finishing every last strand of the vegetables!! Be careful with the fish, they are quite spinier than most other fish. Don'texpect much from the cherry pie dessert, it's grocery-bought, unfortunately not from the Door County cherry orchard farms! Read more

Great experience! Make reservations early!! Day before is best. Military discount offered here! Food was good. I do prefer... fried fish but this didn't disappoint. Do understand that there are bones to pick in this fish. There are boneless boilsadvertised if you can't do the bone thing. Just go slow and enjoy chattering while eating/picking! The boiled onions weredelish! Fresh cherry pie for dessert! Drinks included too...all for $24 for the boil. Outdoor patio area was spacious with abeautiful cliff view. Parking will be a bit more effort if during a busy time, but you'll manage. Put a fish boil on your listif visiting! Read more

Loved the fish boil experience! Got plenty of food for $21-23 a person. Would visit again! Fish does have bones so don?t be... surprised to have to pick them out but the fish is amazing!! Be sure to make a reservation and watch the cooking process! Read more