Reviews for Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza & Grille Fish Creek in Fish Creek, WI

We ate here in early October, arriving at 6:15 p.m., and we still had a solid 35-minute wait. It was worth it. We ordered the... Deluxe pizza which was very good. All of the ingredients were very fresh, and they didn't skimp on the tomato sauce. The crustwas not crispy, but was nonetheless tasty. We'd for sure order pizza here again. Read more

Delicious Wood Fire Pizza served in a fun and friendly atmosphere. Highly Recommended. On a scale of (1-5) Cleanliness: 5... (Nice Clean Restaurant) Service: 5 (Server was kind and attentive given the amount of patrons) Food: 4.5 (The PALOMA pizza wasfresh and delicious. I would've preferred my dressing on the side as the Caesar Salad was over dressed. Value: 4 (Solid Valueon the Pizza given the ingredients used. Slight knock on the Caesar Salad though it can feed two.) Read more

From the moment we stopped, we were in love with this place!! The handbrake cheese curds were by far the best I've ever had! The... breding was light and the cheese oozed out with every bite! The pizza was also amazing and so delicious!! We had a wonderfultime!! Read more

Portion size was unexpected. Huge portions even with the petite salad. My guest had the gluten free crust which was not as... crisp as it could have been. The pizza itself was delicious (Paloma). Read more

Wonderful place to stop for some great pizza. The bread basket is delicious and a lot more filling than we realized. If you... order the basket, a small sized pizza will be way more than enough to fill you up. I'm not sure if they take reservations, wedecided to dine here as we drove through town. We waited about 25 minutes for a table which was not at all an issue with howbusy it was. I'm not the biggest beer drinker but there did seem to be a pretty good selection of multiple types of beer ifthat's your thing. Read more

By far our favorite place for pizza when visiting Door County. While there is another location in Sister Bay, we prefer the Fish... Creek location. Still on the main drag, if you park on the street you can leave your vehicle there and hit up some of the localshops. Great service, food comes out fast, and you aren?t rushed out when you are done. The prices are a little higher then someof the establishments in larger cities, but you can?t beat the freshness of the ingredients and the service. Read more

Loved this place! Great atmosphere and everybody was super friendly. They have some cool merchandise as well. Started off with... some outstanding cheese curds. Ranch was a little runny but still tasted great. We ordered a D-Lux pizza with no veggies on onehalf + chicken on the whole pizza. The pizza ended up coming out with no veggies on the one half but there were mushrooms onthat half, but I?ll say that?s my fault for not clarifying ahead of time. Our server Yessenia was quick to offer to make a newpizza for us correct this time. Came out in under 10 minutes and was fantastic. Sauce tasted good and all the toppings lookedvery fresh. Very much recommend this place to anyone traveling to Door County!!! Read more

Great place for a brick oven pie. They have a great selection of fresh toppings and the pizza crust is excellent. The service is... always nice as well and they have a good assortment of drinks and beers. I always try to stop here when in the area. Read more