Reviews for Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard in Randolph, NJ

We had the Swedish Fish Gelato! Yummy !

This Rita?s is by far the best!! I highly recommend coming here. The owner is the sweetest and goes above and beyond for her... customers! Will never go to another location, this one is the best! Read more

Love their water ice. Just wish they'd have more than 1 sugar free flavor at a time. I'm a type 1 diabetic and can't eat the non... sugar free ones. Not sure if they can control that, but at every Rita's I went to, they've had a total of like 5 differentflavors or something. I'd love blue raspberry water ice, but they never have it sugar free. Read more

There was a woman working all by herself yesterday. She had gotten a huge doordash order and there were a few of us customers... waiting in line. I can?t imagine how stressful this was for her and I had no cash to leave a tip:( She was so kind and seriouslydeserves a huge raise!! My Italian ice was also perfect, thanks for the great service. Read more

First time going here best place for frozen treat

We had such an amazing experience at the Rita's in Mt. Olive. From the moment we stepped up to the window, we were greeted by... Bethany who never stopped smiling! She was awesome! My husband and I both got an Italian Ice and she was so happy to help us. Looking forward to going back! Thank you! Read more

My family and I went out for a drive and arrived st Rita's Ice in Flanders. It was easy to view on 206 and there was plenty of... parking. There were two benches located on either side of the order window so you can sit and eat! The staff was knowledgeableand friendly. They served kid sized portions too!! My children loved the ice and the custard was fresh and delicious! Read more

Love this place, if I ask my daughters if they want to come every day, they would come! Their ice cream is so great and they... have different italian ice flavors every day, The staff is amazing, they are always very fast and always smiling, their serviceis great. I would definitely recommend this place as you ice cream shop to go to, you won't be disappointed. Read more