Reviews for Fat Ernie's Cheesesteaks & Hershey's Ice Cream Parlor in Floral Park, NY

Big waste of money, overpriced sandwiches that are mostly bread. Ordered fries that said would come with sauce and didn?t, burnt... bread and sad sandwiches. Read more

Just happened to drive by this place on the way to Staples. Cheesesteak was very good, the steak tasted like it was quality cut.... The sidewinder fries were very crispy and had some nice simple seasoning. It's not the cheapest lunch but the portions are verylarge. I got the medium and I was struggling to finish it. The service was fast and friendly. Next time I'll have my car washednext door so I can take advantage of the discount haha. Read more

Outstanding! I had the Italian Cheesesteak and everything was excellent. The garlic bread was soft and flavorful and the steak... was cooked to perfection. Highly recommended. And don't forget the ice cream! Read more

This is a place for an excellent bite and delicious food! We had the spicy cheese steak (with jalapenos and onion rings) with a... side of sidewinder fries. The meat on the sandwich is flavorful and is of superb quality. The sidewinder fries are fantastic.They're somewhat of a thicker version of curly fries. Not pictured is the milkshake but I assure you it was a darn goodmilkshake. I'll definitely be returning to this spot! Read more

UPDATE: Fat Ernie?s is back!!! Using good steak meat and serving up proper cheesesteaks. Gave the store a call after I finished... my sandwich because it hit the spot! Turns out the owner was the guy making the sandwiches! Glad to see he really cares abouthis business and the product they put out. My regular order: Traditional cheesesteak, American Cheese, Onions, and Bell Pepperson the Garlic Bread. Best cheesesteaks on Long Island!!! I?ll be back on the regular now. Read more

This place has gotten far better now that they?ve switched owners, honestly a complete 180. We even got our SuperBowl party... catered by them! As someone who?s lived half their life in Philly I can strongly say this place is more flavorful and betterquality than any of the over hyped places there. Strongly recommend the fried pickles, that are made fresh daily! Read more

I ordered cheese fries and it came as if my 7 year old made it. The Philly cheesesteak was ok. I paid for extras to be added and... they forgot to add it on. Sorry they will not be getting my money again. Read more

Missed order notes on my sandwich but the sandwich was good. Their marinara sauce was chunky and the mozzarella has hard cheese... that was not melted. Their fries were okay but tasted bitter after a while. Read more