Reviews for New York Pizza and Pints in Flower Mound, TX

Ended up here when the Thai place next door was unexpectedly closed. Started to leave when I realized how expensive it was but... decided it would be worth the extra money to give a new place a try. My wife ordered a meatball grinder and I got the 14' GardenPie. The guy at the counter taking orders didn't seem to speak much English so ordering was a challenge. He seemed unfamiliarwith the menu boards over his head as well so maybe he was new. We got our food in an acceptable time. The "grinder" was tastybut not a traditional grinder as it's on a fairly thin piece of focacia bread. The pizza however wasn't as described on the menuboards. It had fresh tomatoes which I hate and no olives which I love. When I brought it to their attention, they seemed reallyconfused but in their defense offered to make another one to the expected specifications. While we waited, we split the grinderand I was satisfied. Then the guy from the restaurant came over and thrust a piece of paper in front of me showing that therewere supposed to be tomatoes on the garden pizza. He could have simply compared the paper to the overhead menus but insteadseemed to want to confront me to show me I was wrong. Now I'm angry and will never return ???? Read more

There are two pizza places in Flower Mound that are worth the wait and never disappoint: this is our favorite. The food is... always fresh, the staff are pumped and always courteous. Read more

Do not recommend. No taste to pizza. Garlic knots were doughy inside and burnt on outside. Meatball ?sub? was burnt and not on a... sub roll, just burnt bread. Will never try again. Disappointed. Wasted money and kids didn?t eat dinner tonight. Read more

I am from W coast but had the chance to try NY pizza in NYC to $20 brick oven pizza. Our preferred place has been byo (build... your own) pizzeria. @ this place, byo (up to 3 toppings)is only $6!!! Freshly out of oven baked pizza slices are so huge, wecouldn?t finish it. It was very filling & delicious. The crust was perfect. Glad we tried garlic knots. There were severaltables to dine in. Read more

the best pizza I've been trying for many years, the menu is wide and the work team is very kind!!! There are occasions that the... restaurant is very busy but it is worth waiting for that unique taste. Read more

Decided to try this place for lunch and was pleasantly surprised. The pizza is good and came out quickly. As other reviews have... mentioned the pizza slice is huge and I didn?t even attempt the 2 piece special. It?s worth noting there is some extra seatingfurther back along side of kitchen as well. Ill be introducing this place to the family sooner rather than later. Read more

My husband and I enjoyed our experience. The slices were huge, and the beer and wine choices were good. I'm not sure I'd... recommend dining in since the dining area is so small, but it's definitely a restaurant we'd order from again. Prices for thespecialty pizzas seem a little steep, but since I haven't ordered one, I can't say if they're worth the cost or not. Read more

Was super excited to try this new place, upon entering I felt like I was Invading the new teen hangout and was an imposition for... ordering. The employees all with their phones out and lounging. I'm almost afraid to eat my pizza as I watch the trash bagsbeing hauled directly out through the prep and serving area. Sigh! Read more