Reviews for Mangiami Italiano in Fort Atkinson, WI
Outstanding. A jewel in this small town of Fort Atkinson. Fortunately we read the reviews and made a reservation. There were... four of us, each having a different appetizer, main course and desert. All were excellent! Our waiter Sam did an excellent joband then to have the chef (possibly the owner) come out to ask if we enjoyed the meal and thank us for dinning with them made itan outstanding experience. Read more
This restaurant is perfection! Best food I've ever had! We will definitely be back! Nice quiet setting with nostalgic music. I'm... totally obsessed with the food! It is fresh, authentic and amazing! Read more
Honestly the reviews scared me a little but I thought the food was amazing. I had meatballs as an appetizer and it was... incredible but the pasta rags was a drop your fork and push yourself away from the table type of experience. One of the bestpasta dishes I've ever eaten. My wife and I absolutely will go back. Read more
No where on the website says reservations ONLY. Of I could give less than one star? I would! Came in and restaurant was pretty... much empty(literally serving ONE table) and we were turned away, because they only do reservations only! Really! Will not evercome back here again! WILL be telling everyone about hideous service. Really, you cant handle more than a table of 4 plus our 2?Maybe the lack of patrons says more about your food and service. Update: Your response, precisely confirms what I statedoriginally. Can I see the sign on your door from the house? Obviously not! Again only serving ONE table. Instead of arguing withyour customers, update your website and save other customers the trouble. Not that it matters for that joke of a ?restaurant?.The McDonalds down the road offers better service and better food too! I am glad this happened, actually ended up having a greattime somewhere else, that was actually full but still found a way to make room for us. That?s what we call, Great CustomerService! Shame on you! Hells Kitchen, this might be a good project! Read more
My husband and I were in the area for a family reunion and we lucked onto this restaurant. The service and the food were both... fantastic. It's been 6 months but we are both still extolling the best Italian food we have ever eaten. Thankyou for a greatexperience. Read more
Let's start with the good. The artichoke cheese dip and calamari were both very good. Pasta Rags were delicious as always. The... house wine was excellent. I was able to order sauteed spinach which wasn't on the menu and they were glad to do that for us. Itwas very good. Our waiter Sam was pleasant and did a good job . Now for the not-so-good: Seafood dish which was supposed tohave scallops had none which wouldn't be a problem had it been stated before we ordered but she was kind of looking forward tothose. The ribeye was not a good cut of meat even though it was cooked correctly it was just tough. Hindsight... I should havesent it back, but I know restaurants are struggling right now. I hope this one can get back to its old self because it used tobe amazing!!! Read more
What were we thinking - an Italian Restaurant in Ft. Atkinson? I saw pics online and the food looked better then other... restaurants in the area - especially good looked one dish, gnocci in a white sauce with meat & peas, right up my alley. It wasin the online & print menus, but we were told by the server its only a seasonal dish - not available! We should have left rightthen. We didn't, ending up with 2 plates of macaroni & cheese variants (not great, frozen peas) and a starter of freezer burnedperogies. $82 included 2 beers & 2 wines. Were asked if we wanted bread, it wasn't brought out, nor were bread plates, orbalsamic. Wouldn't eat there again, can't recommend it, especially with the 45 minute drive from Madison - an expensive bummer.The only plusses: we had a romantic seat in the window -- felt some cold air but it was lovely. And my date is ultra foxxy. Read more
The food was so good! Menu was limited, but everyone in our group found something to try and loved their meals. Our server, Sam,... was also great! Read more