Reviews for Cafe Italia - Italian Restaurant in Fort Myers, FL

Food looks great ...for those visiting this on Google maps...per their website "new address is 751 Tarpon Bay Road unit... 2 Sanibel Fl 33957 (Right behind the Art gallery). Grand opening sometime in September 2022" Read more

Understated restaurant which serves authentic Italian food that has absolutely delicious and very well priced. Wine prices are... fair as well. Staff are very friendly. We had the crustini, carpaccio Di Manzo, lobster ravioli and the Osso Bucco ravioli andthey were all phenomenal. Having dined in Italy and experienced the real things, Cafe Italia certain delivers the real deal.We'll definitely be coming back to try more dishes and enjoy our new favourites. Read more

MAKE a reservation! I wish my group was able to eat here. We walked over from a nearby hotel with a group of 5 and we?re unable... to be seated an hour from close. We were disappointed as my friend who checked them out online saw the amazing reviews, I can?tsay anything about the food but it all looking amazing and I wish we would have been able to dine in. The only reason I?mwriting a review is because I wish there was something to say they get quite full as we would have called earlier. I was alsoslightly disappointed with how the waitress treated us to let us know we were unable to be seated, although I understand theywere VERY busy. Read more

Delightful lunch with family and friends. Service was friendly and professional. Recommended!

Enzo was delicious! The bread was light and fluffy, everything was well seasoned, and the prosciutto was plentiful!

I have eaten here several times and NEVER been disappointed. It is truly authentic Italian and freshly made in house. Just... ordered takeout, it began to deluge while I waited for my food. The Chef insisted on walking me to my car under anumbrella! These are special people?????????? Read more

Absolutely delicious! The best Italian food I've had in South Florida. It's a small and unpretentious place with a few outdoor... tables. The quality of the ingredients is excellent. I'll definitely be going back again soon! Read more

The food is delicious. I have ordered prosciutto sandwich and it was very tasty and jussy. The Italian beer is very light and... special. And at the end tiramisu cake was perfect. Read more