Reviews for Pappy's Pizza Fort Pierce in Fort Pierce, FL

I've eaten here for over 2 years and never had an issue. Today after ordering delivery and leaving a $9 tip, I was sent the... wrong pizza and called at which point they refused to fix the issue. Incredibly upset will no longer be giving them my business Read more

The Good: Pizza. The pizza we had (cheese, margaritta) were pretty good. We enjoyed it, and if you take my word for it, go for a... thin crust. They?re nice and crispy. Needs improvement: ?Online ordering is very very very difficult. I couldn?t find for mylife how to order a pickup in the app they endorse and offer promo code for (Slice). And then there is their website, whichwouldn?t let us know what we can order and what not. I tried to add their Buffalo chicken and i couldn?t placed order. Keptrefreshing and wouldn?t get through, i then though they may be out of it, then i couldn?t add a veggie in one of my pizza?not agreat experince. ?Options: How can you not have chicken toping option?? Thats basic, innit? Also, every veggie topping for thesame price? Thats lazy!! Overall, good pizza but way to go. I?m a big fan of supporting local resturants over big chains,particularly for pizza, so I?ll contunue to be give Pappy?s chance and will improve my rating if they do. Cheers. Read more

I was beyond disappointed with our food. Menu said "fresh basil" I got burnt dried basil on my Margherita pizza which made it... taste awful not to mention everything was very bland.The garlic knots were not very good and they forgot the marinara saucewhich would definitely helped with the blah flavor. I highly recommend you order from somewhere else. Huge Disappointment. Read more

I ordered a margarita pizza the description is fresh mozzarella, basil, and homemade tomato sauce. The pizza I got was not even... close. The pizza I got was just cheese and slices of tomato. I called for a refund and he told me I got a margarita pizza. Thata margarita pizza was an olive oil base like what does that even mean? I read the description on their site to the person overthe phone and he told me I was wrong. Their website has a picture of a marg pizza and a description of a typical marg pizza. Read more

Great place to go on Saturday nights if you're looking for a friendly fun time. Karoke on Saturdays brings in a great mix of... people ???? Abby makes sure your drinks are served fast & cold. Jason the Karaoke host has all genres. There's something foreveryone. Take a chance. Karoke Saturdays from 9pm-2am. They also host an open ???? night on Wednesday same hours as Saturday.Bring your own instrument, poetry or karoke as well. Pizza parlor for take out & a fully stocked liquor store to boot! Youcan't go wrong! Read more

I?ve eaten here before and it was good. Tonight it was cold and stale. We drove it home and we live less than 15 min away. And... it was stone cold, literally no cheese on the pizza and very old dough. I seriously feel that it was prepped and cooked for arush on Super Bowl Sunday and given to us after being reheated. So sorry to say it tasted and chewed like microwave pizza. Itried to call three times to say something and when asked to hold I hung up. I would much rather praise a job well done but whenthree adults each eat one piece or less because they are all hungry and have to stop. Your money has been totally wasted. Read more

Easy to pull into and out of, and continue your commute to wherever you?re headed. Right off I95. Well worth the wait (which was... only a couple minutes) for a delicious, piping hot fresh pie and you CANNOT STOP HERE WITHOUT HAVING THE PAPPY WHEELS! Themarinara sauce is really delicious. The service was great. The woman who took care of us was so attentive. We just happened tobump into it and we?re so glad we did! We don?t know when we will be back in the area but we will definitely stop here. Theytold us that there are some great specials on the Pappy wheels on Wednesday?s too! Read more

New to area searching for good Italian pizza subs ect.. Read reviews.. However the " sausage & peppers" was extremely... disappointing. The bread was soggy mess. The peppers were raw not sauted and lacked onions. The sausage was dry circles- forthe pizza toppings. I threw away my $$$ .. So frustrating. Pizza had congealed cheese . This is a joke. Read more