Reviews for Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Fort Worth, TX

We have been ordering our Thanksgiving pies here for several years. The taste and quality have been consistently exceptional.... This year, our pies were priced the same as before, but contained only HALF of the filling as before! The taste was wonderful asbefore, but apparently they have cheapened their product instead of increasing the price? So disappointed in this. Feel like itis a ?bait and switch?; we would gladly have paid a higher price for the size of pie we are used to. But substituting a lesserproduct without letting us know is a deceptive practice. Sadly, we will probably go elsewhere from now on. Read more

Delicious pies! We had the granny apple and buttermilk 4 inch pies. The lady who served us was so nice and friendly. We will... definitely be back to try their other pies. Read more

THE BEST pie shop ever! The staff is so nice & helpful & puts a lot of love in their baking. Other locations don't compare to... this one! Faves are Key Lime pie, Southern custard pie, cloud cookies, & peanut butter pie. All of their crust seems to be ashortbread which is SO GOOD! Read more

Just happened to be in the Camp Bowie area and spotted the Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop, which is in the same shopping center as la... Madeleine. I've read about the Pie Shop in various publications so my sister and I stopped by. The shop sells a variety of piesranging from pecan, coconut cream, key lime, chewy chocolate chip and my favorite Buttermilk pie. These are just a few of thepies available. I bake my own Buttermilk pie but I wanted to try the shop's version so I ordered the miniature size. My sisterordered a box of the 2 inch pies. ( This is 4 of the shop's top flavors packaged together in one box. And yes they are boxed bythe dozen. ) I brought my pie home and enjoyed it with a hot cup of coffee ?. Thumbs Up ????to The Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop .The pie ???? was delicious. I'm looking forward to going back to try some of the other pies in the shop. Read more

Just take my money please, I need your pie's! It's always fun surprising the family with a sweet treat. I went big and got a... full pie but they have smaller options. My suggestion is to get 3 or 4 small pies and try them. My favorite are key lime andthen chocolate, the crust on the chocolate is amazing. Actually, can we request the chocolate pie crust cookie!?!? Read more

Fabulous pies. You cannot beat the quality or presentation. They have become a tradition at family gatherings. Super friendly... and accommodating staff. Gluten free options (call ahead). Read more

Hands down one of my favorite pie shops in Fort Worth. I always order online to make sure I get what I want. If you like a... well-balanced Apple pie (tart filling, sweet and crumbling topping, and flaky crust) this place has it. Read more

This was my first time going and it was a great experience. The staff member that assisted me was very informative. I ended up... buying 4 4in pies for $16 which was a great deal. The I 40 pie is the only one I didn't care for due to the abundant coconut. Iloved the chocolate chip and the pecan was decent as well. The last one was given to someone so I'm not sure about how the keylime pie tastes. Read more