Reviews for Wegner's St. Martins Inn in Franklin, WI

We were in the area so stopped based on the recent Milwaukee Magazine article. My wife ordered a pork chop dinner off the... regular menu and said everything was great. I ordered one of the nightly specials, a bone-in Kansas City strip steak with bakedpotato, sautéed mushrooms and onions. I ordered the steak medium but I could tell as soon as I started to cut it that it wasunderdone. After cutting through it, it was clearly cooked rare at best with some parts I would call even close to barely cookedat all looking more like raw meat. In addition, there was also an unusual amount of silver skin which is totally inedible. Thewaitress, who was wonderful by the way, explained when we arrived that they were short handed. We could see that she was runningaround like mad trying to cover more tables than she normally would and so l didn't want to add to her burden by sending my mealback. I ended up taking more than half of it home to reheat/cook it properly for, I don't know, steak and eggs? Tipped well forour waitress's sake as she was great and doing the best she could. In hindsight, I wish I would have ordered anything else, likethe German food they're noted for instead. As far as I'm concerned, they should stay away from steak. I didn't see steak ontheir menu at all but thought if it's a special it would be a safe bet. Maybe if the chef used an instant-read thermometer hecould know the cut of meat is Read more

Opens at 4 , be there by 3. Small bar and restaurant. Local favorite. All food is good.The fish fry is very very good. Another... reason to get there early. Limited parking. It doesn't get more neighborhood than Wegner's. Read more

Enjoyed the food. Menu was small and to the point. Make reservations it was a full house.

The variety of food was wonderful. A very good selection. The 4 of us had 4 different main entries and they were all excellent.... The chef and owner are the same person, and he does a great job. A family run business that made us feel like we were family.Will definitely return. Read more

Fish was delicious! Went on a Friday night during lent. Waited only 20 min or so at bar. I started with a clam chowder that was... very very good. Chowder had Red potatoes, good seasoning, and bits of clam that blended well. On to the fried cod?The fishbatter was buttery, seasoned just right, and had excellent texture. The batter complimented the flavors of the cod that wascooked perfectly. The tartar was tangy and well made. Cole slaw had a sweet and creamy taste that melded well with everythingelse. Also I ordered the German potato salad that was Smokey and sweet. Wait staff was lovely. I highly recommended Wegner?sfish fry. @bestfry_mke has good fish fry reviews on IG Read more

Like going back in time, to an old fashion Supper Club. The building was build in 1886, and has a history. Great food, and above... average service. A real gem. Read more

My wife and I have been coming here for years. It has been awhile since our last time with the pandemic and all. We ordered fish... fries and picked them up curbside which is really nice. Mine was a perch fry with fries ($18.65) and was really good, my wifehad a three piece haddock ($12.75)with potato pancakes and was very disappointed, the pancakes were very hard and the fish wasway overcooked, you could see it in the crust and taste it. I could have rated it lower but I know this isn?t the normal forthem. We will still go back and give it another go. Sometimes it is better to dine in as you can compliment or complain rightaway. Perch is on the right. Read more

Tried the Friday night fish sampler. Shrimp and perch were great. Cod was OK. Scallops were disappointing as the breading... overpowered the flavor. Coleslaw was tasty as was the potato pancakes. Read more