Reviews for Peppy's Pizza & Subs in Fredericktown, OH
Love Peppy?s my pizza was so amazing and fresh out of the oven the perfect temperature with lots of toppings!
Food was cold even though I was there early for pick up. Do not order a "6" inch sub unless what you really want is a 3 inch... sub. The subs are on about half the size as advertised, and have hardly anything on them on top of that. Overall terribleexperience. Have ate here for 36 years and since changing owners, everything about this place has just steadily gotten worse.Lower quality food and staff on top of ridiculously overpriced menu is why I will not be dining here again. Read more
Ordered two pizzas but due to a mix up only one was made. They said they would make the second pizza at no charge if I could... wait! After 15 minutes or so the second one was done and I was given BOTH pizzas for NO CHARGE!!! They turned a unfortunate.mixup in to good experience for me. Read more
Hands down, the best pizza around. Love the crunch that the cast iron ovens give the crust. Fresh and delicious! Plus, a polite,... wonderful crew. Read more
Best pizza I've ever had. Nice thin crust. Lots'o toppings. Awesome sauce. Usually accurate order got messed up. Because the... person taking my order didn't know their menu. The women running the shift replace the incorrect pizza, but refuse to remake theother two and said she'd keep them in the warmer. Despite my objection. Sure enough it wasn't the same as fresh. Verydisappointed. Don't go unless the owner is there. The "B" crew doesn't care. Read more
I am on a mission to try every local pizza shop (Knox county), and beyond, searching for the best mom and pop pizza, I can... find... Seems I probably won't have to look to far beyond Peppys, as it's been the front runner for many years. Always apleasant experience. Quick and efficient staff, friendly, and the absolute best pizza! Great for take out, or dine-in!Typically takes 30minutes or less, inside is very clean and pays homage to the community sports, and high school. There is ampleseating, which you cannot find in many local shops, that gives you the opportunity to eat inside comfortably. Prices arereasonable and in line with most pizza places. Just a great hometown pizza joint with the best atmosphere, service, food, andprices. Highly recommend! Read more
AMAZING as Usual! The last time I was here was when I was 14/15 years old! This was the "hang out" when I was a kid. It's a... MUST STOP for AMAZING pizza and subs and calzones aka strombolis, lol. The only thing it's missing is feta cheese, that theydon't have unfortunately. Read more
Friendly staff, great pizza and subs. Recommend trying it to see if it's your type of pizza too.