Reviews for Romeo’s Pizza Italian American in Freehold, NJ

For the vegans: best customer service ever. I ordered a vegan pizza and somehow accidentally ordered real-meat pepperoni on it... because I can?t read. I called to double check that it was in fact meat before throwing it out, and the owner told me if I cameto pick it up, they would make me a pizza on the house, even though it was my mistake because they didn?t want to leave ushungry. I went to grab the food and brought money to tip, and the owner refused and said it was on the house. It was also 10minutes before closing, and they still took the time to get us food. Absolute nicest people, and easiest and most cost efficientplace to get good vegan pizza in the freehold area. I appreciate getting dinner for less than $50 from kind folks. Thanks y?all! Read more

This Salad works pizza is incredibly awesome.... Never in my life would I have thought of ordering this... Now it will be a... staple on. Friday nights. Read more

I attended a very fun event at Romeo's this week! The food was amazing, the vibe/atmosphere was very lively and modern, I had a... wonderful time. I've already been back to eat once since! Will definitely continue to return, it's my new weekly spot! I alsoquite appreciate the caution they take when cooking/making gluten free food, the gf pie is made in a special tinfoil so my pizzahas no cross contact in the oven. Thank you!! Read more

If I could give this 10 stars, I would. Today I stopped in and ate a personal pizza that the very nice gentleman said he would... make for me even though it wasn?t on the menu. I had him add green peppers. This was the best pizza I have had in years andyears. I grew up in Jersey and we expect the best when it comes to pizza. This was thin, but not too thin, and was crispy. butnot too crispy and the slice held it?s own when I picked it up. The bottom was perfectly cooked as well, not over done or underdone. There was plenty of gooey perfect cheese and sauce. On top of the perfection of the pizza, he helped me out immediatelyand was on the ball with service. Honestly, it reminded me of pizza I had growing up. Nothing has come close to this inyears. Treat yourself and stop in. Thank you so much!! I will be treating myself again soon!!! I only wish I rook a picture! Read more

I ordered a whole chicken parm sub without the red sauce and asked for vodka sauce. I went to pick it up and was so looking... forward to an awesome sub but when I got home, the sub was so disappointing. The bread wasn't toasted and there was hardly anysauce on it so that made it very dry. I had told my fiancee how amazing the chicken parm sub was going to be with the vodkasauce instead of the red sauce and when he opened it he was not impressed. Neither was I, but we were so hungry we ate it anywayand it was closer to the end of the night so we couldn't bring it back and ordering somewhere else wasn't an option. So needlessto say we'll never be ordering from there again. I've included a picture but it's hard to see that the bread wasn't toasted, butyou can see how there is very little sauce. Read more

The food is absolutely amazing. We have ordered in and eaten at the restuarant several times. As good as any high end Italian... restuarant. Always delicious. And their resultant is a really fun casual atmosphere to dine in. The staff is great!!! Read more

The BEST VEGAN food and service. Thank you Lino, for going above and beyond to making sure my kids with food allergies could... enjoy this amazing food!! I really appreciate it and will definitely be back. I live an hour away, but it is worth it. Hedefinitely knows his ingredients and how to safely prepare food for people with food allergies! Read more

Honestly, this is our favorite. The entrees are super authentic. The food is fantastic. Our family loves coming so we made... it our Friday Night spot!!!! Keep up the great work. Read more