Reviews for Brooklyn Brothers Pizza in Gainesville, VA

We were driving back from a nice day in Shenandoah National Park and were looking for place to have dinner. We were driving on... Route 29 and remembered there was a shopping center at the intersection where we were approaching but didn't know what was therefor sure. Turning in we discovered Brooklyn Brothers Pizzeria. We ordered from the menu and enjoyed an appetizer while we waitedfor the main course. Like the appetizer, we were so appreciative of how hot and fresh the wood was! We like leftovers forlunches during the week, but the food was so good that we cleaned our plates with nothing left over. We wish we lived closer tothis restaurant because we would frequent it much more regularly. If you great tasting food with great customer service andgreat prices, check this place out. We will go again and have pizza and believe we will find it to be just as fresh and tasty asthe meal we had already. I definitely recommend this restaurant. Read more

Coming from NY but living in VA we?re always looking for authentic NY pizza. Found it! Fresh marinara, fresh mozzarella, light... and crispy crust with a chewy interior and great flavor?it had it all. Loved the decor and service as well. Saved this placefor our trips to DC. Read more

Good pizza. Good menu selection. Only issue I had was when ordering online there?s no estimated ready time. You get 2 emails... none with a time. And then when it?s ready, nothing. Definitely would be helpful and would have given it 5 stars then. Anothervisit. Not good at all. Pizza toppings and crust had absolutely no flavor. Service is very friendly. Also still no times givenfor carryout orders. This will be my last visit. Read more

Still a great family Italian restaurant. Have been coming here for several years and will continue to come back. Chicken parm is... delicious!! Good place to get a close as you can get ANY style pizza. Very friendly and down to earth waiter. I group up onNY style pizza and this place hits all the right triggers for me. Thin crust good homemade sauce and cheese that covers the pieand stretches just enough when you bite it. I also had a meatball sub with great homemade meatballs. They really should use achabahtta bread for the meat sandwich. Overall friendly and good food. Read more

The food was great. So fresh the I had the steak and cheese it was so so good. Nice calm environment. I live in DC and this is a... gem that I will come back for. They brought three pizzas to our table they looked very delicious I didn't eat it but it smelledso lovely. The waiter knew alot about the menu and what was the best choice. I will be back very soon with my family Read more

Amazing pizza, very friendly staff. Clean and inviting environment.

Tasty, think crust pizza and salads. The server was quick with the drinks and menu recommendations. We all enjoyed it.

This is a great pizza place that is hidden in this shopping strip. We started with the calamari, it was a little thicker than I... am used to but it was still very good. I also had a Caesar salad which was very fresh. We got a 16-in sausage pepperonimushroom and onion and it is probably one of my top five favorites in the area. I love the taste that the brick oven offers andthe wait staff were very pleasant and friendly as well as top notch service. I will definitely be coming back for more. Read more