Reviews for Winslow's Restaurant in Gansevoort, NY
We had a great family dinner celebrating a very happy 70th birthday for my FIL! The food was delicious, the waitstaff was... friendly and accommodating. Read more
No Turkey Again. 7 PM out of Turkey. Unbelievable. Everything else in the menu isn?t that good. I made a reservation and told... them we want the Turkey. ?No problem we have plenty?. Cannot Recommend anything but the Turkey. Crab cakes tasted like bbq.Stuffed mushrooms where raw un cooked. Cheese Burger. Good taste The staff is A+++. Awesome people? they said. Supply Chainissues. Small Turkeys. No Turkeys. Etc. but if your entire reputation rests on serving delicious Turkey dinners with all thefixings. You figure it out. Go to the local Supermarkets. There are plenty of big fat turkeys. Raise the price. But serve whateveryone comes here for. Turkey. Not Crab Cakes with hardly any crab or meatballs and by the way, I?m Italian and your homemadesausage is just as bad as your Crab Cakes. Stick to Turkey. Read more
I'm not even sure where to begin with this review other than to warn you to skip stopping at this establishment for anything. ... Purely low class, charging Saratoga prices for mediocre food. No one greets you, no hostess station. We had to approach thebar and were ignored for several minutes before being addressed to let them know we had arrived for our reservation. We wereseated and, eventually, our terribly trashy and rude waitress asked us if we would like something to drink. To our son whoasked what soda options they had, she snarkedly responded, "Pepsi and Diet Pepsi...sometimes Ginger Ale but not often so Iusually just say Pepsi and Diet Pepsi." We were a 6 person table celebrating a 71st birthday. I politely asked for Frenchonion soup without bread and the scallop dinner with only asparagus as I do not eat bread or potatoes due to a dietaryrestriction. Her response, with an awful face, "my chef will be very upset at me but I'll write it down". Ok, stop rightthere...I understand if it's a restaurant's policy to not accommodate menu changes but come on... there's a proper way you cango about letting a customer know this and that most certainly was not it! Next, the salads come out. The "Italian dressing" issimple oil & vinegar and the "Ranch" is has an abundance of dill and garlic that is very overwhelming. Fast forward about 20mins and my soup comes out loaded with croutons. When she eventually realizes I am not eating it she says, "oh, he put thebread in anyway, I'll talk to him" She comes back out awhile later and says, "he told me that French onion soup can not bemade without croutons or the cheese sinks to the bottom and burns" I can't even have a response to this statement as I'mdumbfounded by it. I order French onion soup all over (for instance, the Olde Bryan Inn that makes the most perfect one!) andhave never heard of anything so idiotic. She also let me know that I could not have asparagus because he only had enough Read more
Does anyone know if Winslow?s has turkey dinner? :-) Wow! What an awesome meal! When they say turkey dinner, they aren?t... kidding. Be prepared to do the Thanksgiving after nap. It?s a lot of food. 2 meals for most. Great atmosphere, waitresses arevery kind and polite. Definitely will be one of our go-to?s. Read more
My best friend recommended this place to us and the Service and food were amazing! Joanne was an amazing waitress!! So kind and... attentive even though they were busy she was on top of our needs. Couldn?t have asked for a better first experience at anestablishment. I would highly recommend them to anyone just make a reservation if your going during busy times. Read more
If you?re looking for delicious Italian food, you?ll find it at Winslow?s. You?ll find dishes like chicken piccata, chicken... parm, and eggplant parm (prepared how it should be?lightly fried without bread crumbs). Our table ordered all three of thoseentrees and loved everything. Entrees come with choice of soup or a side salad with homemade croutons and your choice ofdressing. Our server, Hannah, was awesome, too. She took great care of us and was a pleasure to chat with. We?ll definitely beback! Read more
I just had the most delicious cream of mushroom soup with roasted garlic. I wish I had a gallon to bring home. I went expecting... I was going to get the turkey dinner but then I saw the Grilled Diver Sea Scallops with mushroom risotto. It was so deliciousand the scallops were very tender and cooked to perfection. My father got the turkey dinner which never disappoints, tender andmoist turkey...yum. Read more
I would never recommend this place. I ordered their $32 steak and the baked onion soup. Soup was warm cheese barely melted.... Steak. Steak was tuff. Our friends order the crab cakes and the spaghetti with meatballs. The sauce was bitter and tasted out ofthe can and was told her crab cake tasted like kerosene. The waitress was new and had no idea about anything. Every time weasked a question she had to go ask someone for the answer. Waitress came by and said how is everything and we said the steak istuff she smiled and walked away My dog doest mind the tough steak ????. Read more