Reviews for Maggiano's Little Italy in Garden City, NY

Our first time there for a baby shower. We were greeted by Dave with a warm and welcoming smile. Very helpful and accommodating.... Delicious food was served family style and abundantly. Service was on point. Dessert was the perfect ending to a wonderful meal.Looking forward to going back to take friends and family for dinner. From someone in the hospitality business, happy to say5-stars all the way. Read more

We made reservations about 15 minutes before arriving, which we were thankful for. We waited no more than 5 minutes to be... seated by a very friendly young lady. The choices are exactly what you would expect from an Italian-American restaurant filledwith Nonna's traditional recipes . The service and food was outstanding. The quality and portions was excellent. Most high endrestaurants do not give you enough food and they charge you a fortune but not here. I highly recommend Maggiano's for a goodquality meal. Read more

Came here for happy hour and definitely not disappointed. Though their happy hour menu is not extensive but their flatbread... pizza is a winning deal at $4 each with your choices of margarita or sausage. I highly recommend taking advantage. Happy hourIncludes vast selection of beers, wines, cocktails and mixed drinks. They also have a full bar in case you decide on somethingdifferent. Overall this is a great location to unwind for happy hour with great ambience and minimal noise level. Read more

If you love cheese & other 'dairy heavy' foods then you'll be in heaven here: VERY heavy on the cheese, even in the salad. ... Service was meh (had to wait close to an hr for a table and we had a reservation)... our server really tried to make us feelcomfortable but the long wait between each course of the meal was too much... the food tasted okay but the desserts wereamazing. Tip: 1. don't go on a weekend, if you do expect delayed service ( or order from the bar so you don't realize ????)2.Call B4 you arrive for your reservation to be sure your table is ready Read more

I went to birthday party in this restaurant and loved it. Food was fantastic and our server Maria was excellent. Food quality... and portion was excellent. Place was crowded but after pandemic, it was good to see that life has resume like before. Read more

Awesome meal with my hubby. We're at the bar, nice waitress . The Alfredo sauce was awesome sauce ???? ???? ???????? Michelle... our waitress was so much fun and very personable. We will come again! Please get the Gigi butter cake you will not bedisappointed!!!????????????????????? Read more

Came here to dinner on a Friday night actually it was Black Friday if I remember correctly. We did an online reservation 20min... before arriving and got seated right away which was awesome. I was with my wife and my 2 youngest kids. The place was very dimand didn’t have a place to place your coats; which bothered me because we know that takes up seating space but aside from thatI’ll say the food and customer service was awesome!! My wife loved her seafood platter and the boys their pizza! I had somesteak and liked it very much too. Conveniently right by the Roosevelt Field Mall and easy to get to; I’d highly recommend thisplace. Read more

Delicious! Made a reservation for a Saturday night, got there and was seated immediately and were served warm bread while out... drink orders were put in. Great atmosphere with the cute red and white table clothes. Server was attentive and knew the menu. Food was delicious and desserts were large portions. Read more