Reviews for Caribbean Custard & Italian Ice in Garden City, UT

Great chairs, awesome music, good and ready service. I had lots of good sun with a nice breeze. They have gelato, shakes and... Italian ice. Perfect place to chill and enjoy some ice cream. Read more

Family environment they have a nice area with places to sit and wait for your order or enjoy your Caribbean Custard & Italian... Ice. We waited about 15 minutes to place our order. The waiting queue it?s created because everyone has to place their orderelectronically with their electronic interactive menu before you can get to the register. It?s a very modern menu :). I wouldrecommend for a staff member to stand by to recommend flavors or answer questions. We waited another 10 minutes to receive our 7small cups of custard & Italian Ice. The price is moderate but, it?s very tasty. I recommend this place the next time you arelooking for a sweet and refreshing treat. Read more

The family has been getting famous Bear Lake raspberry shakes for 40 years. This is the first time that I?ve felt a place had... something to write about. Ice cream was custard (makes a HUGE) difference. Other ingredients were fresh. Loved being able toselect a ton of different mix ins. There is no need to go to any other place to get shakes. Incredibly helpful staff. Wasseriously impressed. Read more

This place was super busy and does a pretty good job! Great environment and waiting area. The only thing really holding it back... was the wait times. We had to wait about 40 minutes for our two raspberry shakes and two sodas. They had very friendly staff andfor every one person they served three more joined the queue. There is room for improvement but they\'re doing a good job. Read more

What a great spot!\nBetween the family I got to try the Tigers Blood, Cotton Candy, and Peach Italian Ice. They were all... delicious! We also got a concrete shake which was creamy and amazing.\nThe staff were great. The location had nice open grassand lots of seating and was well shaded in the evening. Stop by! Read more

Best Italian ice and custard ever. Stopped by for the first time this past weekend. The staff was so fun and friendly. They have... the cutest decor setup out front. I had no idea that just getting a custard that I would find out all the cool stuff fireflyhas to offer. They rent E bikes, electric surf boards, electric body boards, cabin , Utvs and more. Check out their website. Somuch fun events and things to do in Bearlake this summer. Read more

Excellent treats, fun atmosphere, very nice and helpful staff!\nMy family and I stopped here to get a treat. We?ve never been in... to Italian Ice or gelato. The staff was very prompt to provide samples of whatever we wanted. After ordering, we briefly waitedas they prepared our order and the owner came out to check on everyone. He was even more friendly!\nWe will definitely be back! Read more

Brand new spot in Garden City, Utah. Amazing gelatos, Italian ice, custards, shakes, and concretes. Loving my apple pie concrete... with cheesecake mix in. Family-owned. Super-friendly staff. Come in to sample the freshly-made flavors, or download the app toorder ahead! Read more