Reviews for Avellino's Pizzeria & Catering in Garden City South, NY

I catered from here for my graduation party. Everything was amazing, all my guests loved the food and asked me where the food... was from. We got the food delivered and the guy who came to deliver the food set up everything on the serving table and turnedon the gel chafing fuel for us as my dad drank his beer and I was inside getting ready. Thank you so much :) Read more

Got the Sunday special. Food is good but it does not serve 6-8 people unless your family eats like birds which my does not. ... More like serves 4-5. :) Read more

Pizza made me feel sick. There are too many good pizza places around to mess with this place ever again.

They make the cauliflower pizza taste like a real regular slice I was in disbelief were I called the store to make sure since I... am gluten intolerant. Awesome pizza ! Read more

I'd give this place minus five stars if I could. How can you screw up basic Italian food? Dried out chicken wings, mixed up... orders . . . incredible. They consistently overcharge because their staff can't calculate the taxes correctly, much lessaccurately add up the bill. And as for their "specials," they search for every possible way to refuse to honor them. This hasnot been a one-time occurrence. There are a million cheap pizzerias to patronize, but this is not one of them. Basta! Read more

Best pizza in town. Tried for the first time. Had the Sicilian which was delish and the Chicago style which was over the top... delish!!! You can really see that they use VERY HIGH quality ingredients. Can?t wait to go back. Read more

The manager Joe is very disrespectful. I ordered honey wings and when I opened the container, there was a hair on my food!!! I... also ordered penne bolognese and it was so bland and disgusting I couldn't even eat it. I called to complain and Joe was veryrude and flat out yelled at me for daring to say that his food was awful. He insisted that the food was good and asked me if Itasted it. Of course I did! It's how I was able to tell you the food was awful. He was very condescending and I will never getfood from there again. His customer service skills are in need of significant improvement. He was mad at me for daring to saythat his food was mediocre at best. Read more

I've lived in the area for my whole life. Remember this place when it was Centurion, and they had great pizza and a warm family... environment. I tried to buy pizza here a few times, and the owner has got to be one of the rudest people on earth. He doesn'tseem to care at all. If you buy online as well he doesn't look at the orders. Either he has never run a retail store before orjust simply is not interested, but this is not the business he should pursue moving forward. He's in the wrong industry. Plentyof great pizza options in the area without having to deal with the drama. Read more