Reviews for Geraci's Restaurant Mayfield Village in Gates Mills, OH

It was okay, just not great. When she cut my slice out, I lose quite a bit of the pizza. The taste was good, but the sausage... wasn't great. I like a hearty chunky sausage recipe, this was like crumbly school cafeteria stuff, which does bring back findmemories, but I expected more. Read more

Ordered the small deluxe with the intent on eating half.... I couldn't stop and ate the whole pizza it was so good!

This is another location of the legendary one from in town. Well I can't say it was quite as good as the other two locations the... pizza did hit the spot. When you have been eating Geraci's sinc you could walk your expectations are high, that being said youwon't be disappointed with the pizza here. Read more

Cannoli was great!! Single slice pizza was ok. We got pepperoni and a cheese. Sauce wasnt my favorite, but wasnt the worse i... have had. Salad was delish. Super friendly and personable. Allowed to eat inside. Clean table before and after. Socialdistancing. Love that the cooks and other staff all wearing masks. Price wasnt bad. Would love to try again, but a differentstyle pizza with hopes of it tasting better. Still gave 4 stars because it was a great experience. Read more

Paid $23 for a large beef and spinach pizza. It was nasty. Idk maybe its the tomatoes throwing me off but wasn't at all what i... expected. Read more

I 've had Geraci's pie for 36 years. I believe their pizza is as good as, or even better than NY style pizza. I had friends come... in from NY and they said it's just as good as home. That's a bold statement coming from a New Yorker! Geraci's sauce isridiculous. Their sausage is a crumbled topping...my favorite topping. Trust me... you won't be disappointed. Read more

Pizza is one of my favorite foods. Our 1st time eating Geraci's Pizza and we will definitely order again. We got our usual:... large cheese pie with extra sauce, tomatoes, mushrooms, and black olives. It was sooo good. The sauce and cheese were almost upto the edge. Tried the Tirimasu and each fork full was so creamy and delicious. Called 3x--once to order and 2x to change. Womantaking the order was kind and patient. The pizza was ready when stated. I'm only sorry I haven't try it sooner. Read more

I ordered a pizza with cheese half pepperoni and sausage. OMGoodness, it was fabulous. My 5 year old granddaughter took one... bite, grabbed a slice for each hand and shouted this is the best pizza ???? ever! I also ordered wedding soup. WOW, WOW, WOW,hands down the best wedding soup I have ever tasted. Great people, I met the chef who has been with the Geraci's for 35 years,that tells how special this place is. I left my credit card there by mistake and they kept it safe for me. I look forward tomore wedding soup and pizza. I can't wait to visit the new Pepper Pike location. Amazing!!! Read more