Reviews for Cellar The in Geneseo, IL
My family and I enjoyed one of the BEST tasting steaks ever! My NY Strip was cooked to perfection, bake potato and side of... veggies were perfect and my house salad with their in-house green dressing was very good. We topped our dinner off with a verytasty carrot cake. Our server was very professional and did an outstanding job! I will definitely return if I'm ever in the areaagain. This is the place to go if you are looking for a great tasting steak for a reasonable price. Read more
Had a private party of 30 people. Made us order from limited menu, didn't let us order appetizers. Some tables didn't get... enough rolls for everyone seated, when asking forore were told no. Many steaks weren't cooked correctly, when asked to fixacted like it was a big deal. Waitress said she wished we had gone somewhere else to eat. Absolutely the worst service of mylife. Will never be back. Over priced and terrible service. Read more
Service (Sherry) was great, attentive and cheerful; food (orange roughy) was superb (with house salad and mixed vegetables);... atmosphere was charming and comfortable (with local artist's work displayed throughout). Return worthy? Absolutely! Read more
Always an excellent experience coming here. True professionals is running a restaurant. Great host, wait staff and chefs.... Wonderful attention to detail and the food is superb. Thank you again! Read more
First time here last night and it was phenomenal! Our waitress was incredible in every way possible! My food was absolutely... delicious and the way they celebrate birthdays is awesome! They cut and serve cake for your whole party! Will definitely beback!! Read more
Been going here for years. Award winning charcoal grilled steaks. New York strip is my go too delicious and tender. Old school... supper club vibe and yes it's in the cellar. Two good size dining rooms with a full bar and a separate party room. Some gamingmachines in the bar. Some crackers with a delicious cheese spread to start. Recommend the onion rings and mushrooms as aappetizer. Steaks and Catfish are always great here. Free sticky buns as a dessert after your meal also have several paidselections as well. Large variety of table sizes so no matter your group size they can seat you. Reservations are recommendedmost nights. This place has been around forever for a reason, give them a try you'll love it. Read more
This is A DESTINATION LOCATION for old-school, melt in your mouth steaks, fine dining, perfect cold martini, complimentary... cheese spread and cracker basket, green goddess dressing with an experienced and lovely wait staff. Just go. Stop reading. Go.Oh yeah make a reservation. This place is busy Read more
The Cellar never disappoints! I had what I call the Midwest Surf & Turf - Fried Cat Fish w/ a Filet! The quality has always... been great!!! Read more