Reviews for Aurelio's Pizza of Geneva in Geneva, IL
This place was recommended by a good friend, but we were not fans at all. They use a different kind of sauce, and maybe even... cheese, but it just wasn't to our liking. It was a very busy place so a lot of people must have enjoyed it. Our waitress wasawesome tho, and it was a cool looking place. Just didn't enjoy the food. Read more
Wow this is such a disappointment. Soggy, heavily breaded calamari with no tentacles and they left out the fresh lemons... requested. The pizza was okay that is why 2 stars. I won't be back. Read more
Unfortunately had an awful experience here tonight. Food is usually amazing but this particular location?s organization and... servers/hostesses can use serious improvement. Party of two waited an hour after being told only 15m, then was seated but noserver even batted an eye for 30mins, the owners didn?t do it either, we just called it. We had several parties of 4 or morecome in with no reservation and sat with ease? they even noticed us and said ?wow, sorry guys.? Understaffed, maybe, but atleast stop in and order our drinks or at the very least give us an ETA as to when you will be circling back. Management shouldhave better prepared when a band is playing ? offer incentives, the out of pocket expense will balance out, I promise. We wereable to get a hot competitor, Pal Joeys, with ease thankfully to get our pizza craving in! Read more
First of all, this is my favorite pizza out in the burbs, (and we came here from Chicago with all the best pizza options... available to us). We had a smooth easy fun event here on the patio. The management was so helpful and laid back. They set asidehalf the patio for our baptism lunch. The managers Tim and Tyler helped us spin up just the perfect amount of food (pizzas,pastas, salads) and they even allowed us to drop our cake off to be stored on site the evening before since we would be comingstraight from church. Our family was happy with the arrangements we made. The food was reasonably priced for a group event. Weeven had a backup plan to move inside that day as the chance of rain was about 50/50 the day before. I?ll have to add foodphotos on another visit, but we have also enjoyed their appetizers and salads on regular lunch visits, and pizza for carry out.My favorite appetizer is the grilled jalapeño poppers. We also got to try the private party room when we were invited to afriends birthday. It was a tight squeeze for a large group but would work well enough for 15-20. There is parking nearby in thepublic lots down the street, as parking in the private lot is limited. Read more
Great pizza and great conversation out on the patio. We never miss a night at aurelios when we are in the tri-cities!
Excellent!!! We ate on a busy Friday night. As the shirt says "it's in the sauce." You don't often find pizza sauce on the sweet... side, but that's why I love it. The cheese and thin crust work together to balance the flavor and bring it home!! Also a familyfavorite is the antipasto salad. Read more
I have always been hesitant to get pizza here because of the price. Had it for the first time and WOW was it great. Officially... my new favorite pizza. My only regret- not dinning in, band outside and atmosphere was great! Read more
Ordered a small, thin crust Supreme-type pizza (sausage, pepperoni, etc.). Crust was soggy. The cheese and sauce had very little... taste. Cost $27; definitely not worth it. Read more