Reviews for Old Mill Winery in Geneva, OH
Nice little place. Enjoyed the spaghetti and meatballs and salad. UNfortunately, the table next to us had the loudest people... I've heard in public in quite a while. This woman more closely resembled a loudspeaker than a human. A thoroughly obnoxiousperson who knew she was loud, and didn't care. The few moments when the VOICE stopped, I could enjoy myself, but then shestarted back up again. The place, being kind of rustic (and charmingly so!) has a lot of hard surfaces that allow the sounds ofa completely rude and arrogant drunk woman to reverberate and shatter your eardrums, so be warned. Otherwise: good place. Read more
Food & spirits are awesome. They even offer a veggie burger for the non-carnivores. Delicious food. Very clean & great staff.... Our waitress Jaydin was hands down AMAZING! So attentive and nice. I will definitely revisit this winery. Thank you & pleasethank Jaydin again for me. Read more
Came to the area for a day trip and finished off here for dinner before the long drive home. Couldn't have picked a better place... to enjoy a great meal. From the appetizers to main course as well as the decor inside each had the feel of a home cooked dishthat was prepared with pride. If your not from the area and looking for great food don't skip over this place. Thanks for agreat ending to a fun trip. Read more
Nice atmosphere on a sunny Saturday afternoon. We had spaghetti and meatballs that was pretty good. Unfortunately we also had a... tasteless chorizo sub with zucchini fries that were burned to a crisp. Once I asked to have the fries removed from the bill wedidn?t see anything more of our waitress. This is unusual for Old Mill. ???? Read more
We had a lovely date night here mid week. We made a reservation, but likely didn?t need one. They had a monthly pizza and burger... special, as well as drink specials. We split a bowl of potato soup, which was very good. The beyond burger was exactly asadvertised with chips as a side. The rueben pizza was good. You have a choice between wood fire or pizza crust. We tried woodfire, but would probably do a regular crust next time. We didn?t have room for dessert, but they had cheesecake. Read more
If you are headed to Geneva on the lake this is a must stop. The staff is so kind, and the food is amazing. I forgot to take a... pic of the wine burger but it was cooked to perfection. It was juicy and full of flavor! The wine cheeses appetizer will makeyou want more, and the wine slushees?. I had the peach mango but tried all 3. They will let you sample? we sat at the bar andmade some new friends. It?s worth the hour drive. ???? Read more
Really good food. Wine slush and jack/coke slush was a good touch. I liked the atmosphere of the establishment with indoor and... outdoor seating. Not big on the whole wear a mask for 30 seconds as you walk to your table then take it off. However i get theywant to remain open and in business and it is not their fault. So no gig for them trying to run a business in an unfortunatesituation. Well recommended, with great service and ability to buy by the bottle. Read more
Definitely a wonderful place to dine. Food and wine were excellent. Service was great and service. We loved the atmosphere. Well... recommended. Read more