Reviews for Brother's Pizza in Gettysburg, PA
Our go to spot for Italian food and a glass of wine. Yummy ????
Wings were way over cooked, asked for a cold Italian sub it was hot. Asked and paid for a Sicilian pizza with extra cheese and... received a round pizza with no extra cheese or Pepperoni. Sucks because we are out of town on a trip and this was our spot wechose to eat at. Very disappointing. Read more
Very tasty pizzas and subs.
By far, the best pizza, subs and sides for the price in the area. Every order arrives fresh and piping hot. They use the... freshest and choicest ingredients, and that makes a huge difference in the quality. I'll always recommend Brothers to friendsand family alike. Read more
The lady at the register asked us what our order number was, and we told her and moments later she walked back and asked us... again my I help you, like she never seen us. So we told her again our order number. We Ordered cheese pizzas and cheese steaksubs, we got the cheese pizzas but we got cheese burger subs and decided to try them. They where dry like great value walmarthamburger patties. Don't confuse them, they will mess it up. I do not recommend. I will not go back. Read more
First time I tried Brothers it was for pizza. When we went to pick it up, the cashier had an attitude. I brushed it off and the... pizza wasn't bad. I tried them again, this time for a cheese steak sub. I was way more than disappointed. 4 subs we ordered werenothing but bread and lettuce. There were fries missing and the fries we did get tasted like they spent a while under the heatlamp. Disgusting. I will definitely take my business elsewhere from now on. Don't waste your money here, folks! Read more
The menu has lots of options and great prices. I'm a fan of lunch specials, which they have here! To top it off, Brother's Pizza... now sells cheesecake!!! Read more
We order from this pizza place periodically. We usually get pizza and fries, which are good. Tonight?s order was a Greek... Salad,Cheese Pizza, and Chicken Cheese Steak. Everything was cooked well and tasted amazing! This time I was sure to capture themoment of unveiling what we had in the box and foil wrappers. Kudos to the cook! Thank you for preparing the order as delightfulas it was in just 20 mins. Read more