Reviews for Gladstone Tavern in Peapack and Gladstone, NJ
Beautiful decor, simple and elegant. The wait service was awesome! Paid attention to details and polite. Very pleased with the... food as well. It was fantastic. We got the crispy shrimp bowl, squash soup, and Cuban sandwich. Read more
Best burger I have ever had (and I have had a lot of great burgers ???? including Rocky Hill Inn). Top three at least. It’s... also nice that it’s a short drive from Natirar Park. Perfect for a date! Read more
Cute area. Loved the place!! Staff was friendly and nice, service was quick and the food was good. Do get the pumpkin soup and... cauliflower appetizer, they were delicious!! Read more
Not good! We planned a nice evening with my out of town parents and every aspect was disappointing from the moment we walked in.... We were seated at an inside table which was completely sticky and we had to request it be wiped down. Our drinks took well over20 minutes and we received only part of our table's order. Our server indicated they were out of the feature beer and tookanother 15 minutes to return with the glass of wine that was ordered instead. The featured margarita for the day was supposed tohave some spice to it, but was pretty flavorless. We were there on the last night of their special Lobster week, and both myfather and I were interested in ordering the lobster pre-fixe meal and asked if the chef would crack and disassemble thelobsters for us. The server promptly told us the chef is not willing to do that and we would have to crack it ourselves. We werewilling to pay extra for that service as neither of us wanted to get that messy at a nice meal, so we both ordered somethingelse. Both my dad and husband ordered burgers, my dad with no onions...his came with onions; my husband with cheese...his camewithout cheese and a burger patty that completely fell apart when he picked it up. My daughter was interested in the BBQ ribs,so we asked if it was a full or half rack. It took our server another 15 minutes to check with the kitchen and responded thatthe meal was a full rack, then she came back a little while later to say the portion was actually 6 "big ribs", which of coursewas not a full rack. We ordered them anyhow and requested additional BBQ sauce when they came and waited another 15 minutesbefore she came back to tell us the kitchen was out of BBQ sauce. My mom ordered the crispy shrimp bowl, which ended up being50% frisee lettuce which she does not care for and was not mentioned in the menu description. Every drink refill took at leastanother 20 minutes for wine and beer. The server said the bar was "backed up" but we had a clear view of t Read more
I went here for my sister in law's bridal shower. It was a lovely place. Great venue to host an occasion. Salmon was cooked... perfectly. I normally don't order salmon at restaurants because it is almost always over cooked. But I'm glad to say this placeis one of the exceptions. Read more
Very delicious brunch and friendly, prompt service. Every dish was presented beautifully and tasted great! Felt like I was... eating at a NYC-level restaurant. Highly recommend the lump crab omelet, delicious duck fat fries, chilaquiles and gluten-freechocolate pecan dessert. My husband also enjoyed his seasonal winter gin cocktail. 10/10. We will be back! Read more
Very busy but host accommodated our reserved seating arrangements. Eclectic entree and appetizer choices. Had the iceberg salad... with homemade Roquefort dressing:EXCELLENT. Vegan tofu w peanut sauce: too spicy for me. French fries : very large portion hadskins on them assume homemade. Dessert: apple pie w ice cream and sauce/ had sauce held-tart was just OK-crust was tough notflaky. Friend had the “‘hand churned”’ice cream-do not know how it was. Service very quick efficient but not so friendlybecause I suppose completely packed . Read more
I came here to see brunch with Bobcat and was very impressed. The atmosphere was great and the people were friendly as ever. I... ordered the avocado toast it came out perfectly. I can't wait for the next brunch with bobcat as I shall tell everyone I knowabout it and Gladstone tavern Read more