Reviews for Pharmacy Kitchen & Bar in Goshen, NY
I recently convinced my colleagues to try this place since we order out practically every night for dinner with a large order. I... want to start by saying the food was good, but every other aspect was not. Last week I placed a large to go order at 6:15 PM.When I arrived to pick-up the order I was short a lot of money and when reviewing the receipt there was a 20% gratuity added tomy bill which ended up being $65 in gratuity for this large order. When I asked I was told that the computer automatically adds20% gratuity to bills over $250. We ALWAYS tip regardless on our takeout orders, but that was a shock and something Ishould’ve been advised of when I placed the order. I am not complaining about leaving gratuity, but when you get blindsidedwith a 20% gratuity totaling $65 when you have never experienced that on any takeout order, ever, it was a shock and came out ofmy pocket. That needs to be addressed when someone is placing a large order because that is not normal practice on takeout. Nowafter that horrible incident we decided to go back today with a much smaller order (2 items). We called at 6:08 PM and was toldthat they don’t do any takeout orders past 6 PM! Shocking, considering the week prior I placed a $300 order much after6pm. Only two dealings and both have not been good and clearly inconsistent. I have looked on their website and I don’t seeanything about the 20% added gratuity on takeout orders over $250, and I also don’t see anything about no takeout after 6pm.Hopefully if you decide to try this place, your experiences will be better, or stick to dine-in because obviously there areissues with takeout, but then again I have not eaten in-house so I can’t confirm if the dining experience will be any better.On the plus side their food is very good and they could have made lots of money from me and my colleagues, hence the $300 orderlast week for our first visit and would’ve been regularly. Read more
Deep fried monte Crisco sandwich, I really enjoyed it. Only issue is menus only online . No paper menu offered. A little hard... for some of the non tech people like my husband. Only one waitress on a Sat afternoon. She was busy so service was a littleslow. But not her fault. He had a cuban sandwich, which was good. We had some Oysters on the half shell and an Olive terrine.All in all we enjoyed it , the place used to be a Pharmacy so it was cool decor! Read more
My favorite is the surf n turf burger, crème brûlée was ok. Whiskey sour was excellent. Our waiter was a little off (big guy)... he was not all too nice and a little condescending. Cute nice idea for a restaurant Read more
Amazing!!!!! Delicious steak, delicious drinks, attentive service. My husband is still raving about his ribeye. We are... definitely coming back this is our new date night spot. If you moved up from NYC this will take you back to good eats. A Musttry! Read more
Great service. The atmosphere is great, very adorable - for example the medicine bottle for your receipt. Food is excellent:... fried provolone cheese in marinara and pesto sausages; escargot served untraditional and interesting in a puffy croissant-likedough/pastry and creamy sauce; chicken wings were excellent. T-bone steak was quality meat but it was not done to excellence,it was not best. But still it was good, so counting overall experience with the other dishes and drinks and service leaving 5stars. Cocktails are amazing and unique. Desert: cheesecake is definitely home made, it was fluffy. Service wasexcellent. TIP: make sure you tell them to hold off on the main course! It’s not timed well, so it will come too soon andyou will have to blend it with appetizers. Read more
Excellent food and friendly service, possibly overshadowed by high prices. Two burgers, side of fries, fried provolone appetizer... and 2 beers came to $86. Was expecting $55-$60. Judging by food alone it's 5 stars. Everything was excellent, so didn't mind theprice. But others may not see it the same way. Read more
The atmosphere is everything here! Down to the medicine bottle for your receipt, aptly named drinks, and needle pens, this is... how you you make the details matter without overdoing it. The food was so good and our server, Martha, was warm and friendly. Wewere here for a late lunch, but I can see this place booming on a Friday or Saturday night. We will definitely be back! Read more
Fun, casual restaurant with good vibe, great service, and delicious food. We ate the bacon wrapped shrimp, tuna tartare, and... ahi tuna. All were perfectly prepared, well balanced, and satiating. Read more