Reviews for Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom in Green Bay, WI
We went there after Ghost's concert and the server that was working that night Sept 23-24 was incredibly accommodating and nice.... He was taking good care of us despite the place being a little bit full (it was one of the few places open to eat in. It was mysister's birthday and I told him that, and when we got ready for desert, he pulled me close to the kitchen and handed me theplate with our cake and we both came out to sing happy birthday to my sis. Thank you so so much, I hope you (the server, youwere so sweet) get to read this and get to know you made our day, and my sis' birthday, a great experience. Thank you for beingso great. Oh. And yeah. The food was great. I just needed to gush about this one server. Thank you for having us even if it wasthat late ?? Read more
Bartender and manager treated my amazing while I was visiting from Puerto Rico. Loved the Beer and the free samples. The pizza... was to die for! YUMMY ???? Read more
Took my mom out tonight for her birthday! Absolutely loves the service and the food! The pasta was good, all though the meat... kinda seemed like it was lunch meat, idk it might’ve just been cut different but it was still really good. The fried picklesare the best, I liked how they were seasoned, the mozzarella sticks were good, they weren’t cheesy as much, they were mostlybread. I got the Ma’s Lasagna and personally I wouldn’t get it again tbh it was overcooked and wayyy too greasy. But thereason I give only 3 stars is because the food. Other than that we enjoyed ourselves and had great service. Read more
I really liked the old menu. I'm not sure I'll be coming back here after seeing the new menu. I ordered the crafted beer burger... with cheesy garlic bread. The bread wasn't as good as what they used to serve and the fries they have now are waffle and donthave any seasoning to them. Service was good and friendly. Read more
I live out of state so coming here is a treat for us. Been twice now and both times the food was superb while the waitress was... great. Even for being super busy our waitress always smiled and was pleasant while being at our table. Read more
The food was excellent. Our service was great. We were on a time crunch and the waitress was very kind and helpful in making... sure we were in and out within the short time we had. Cannot wait to go back when we have more time! Read more
Even though it was Homecoming night, we got seated right away. Waitress was very knowledgeable and made good suggestions. Build... your own pizza was great, side salad was fresh. Read more
Cool place, food was great! The waitress I had was the best at her job that I’ve ever seen!!!