Reviews for Papa Johns Pizza in Greencastle, IN
Great service and food. I enjoy getting carryout from this location.
Driver got lost, they forgot an item we ordered but when I called they claim it wasn?t ordered. Manager was extremely rude to... the point I will probably never order again. I ordered online left the driver a 10 dollar tip and the total was 71.13 for 2pizzas but never got my jalapeño popper bites. He did offer to make them but from his attitude you would have thought I shothis dog or something. The last time we ordered they said they couldn?t do a pizza with 1/2 the sauce as usual because it wouldjust run to the other side! That?s the mentality we?re dealing with people!!!! Geez!!!! Read more
Pizza was good. They had 3 large orders at once so it was a longer wait than indicated. Staff is very good and apologized for... the timing. Read more
Carry out on line order. Pizza was ready on time and tasted very good.
Pizza came smash together like it had been dropped or the driver was driving recklessly. Also wasn't cut completely if I didn't... have to wait an hour would have got a refund and I had to bring me a new one. Would love to load a picture to show everyone. Read more
I love going here! The staff is great, I have only had positive experiences every time I come in or order delivery. This one... delivery driver is so awesome, polite, goes above and beyond. There is indoor seating available if you or your family want tosit down to enjoy your meal. They have forks and knives available for those who want or need them. Always adding new things tothe menu. I used to be a die hard Pizza Hut fan but Papa John's thin crust is so much better. Read more
We always get good pizza and bread sticks at this location. I like their wings. Preparation and delivery time is shorter than... expected, even during busy hours. I haven't experienced many mistakes, but in the event of a mistake, it's always immediatelyfixed. Thanks to the folks that work here for making so many meals. Read more
Food was hot and everyone enjoyed the pizza and breadsticks.