Reviews for The Putnam Inn in Greencastle, IN
Overall, it's not a bad place to visit. Their dessert bar is great, the cookies are really good! But I'm a picky eater so it's... hard for me to find what I like on the buffet. The food had a lot of flavor. Just not a ton of options for me Read more
Highly recommend this restaurant for some good home cooking and good variety. The buffet is fantastic, offering a wide array of... fresh, hot homestyle foods. Don't forget to visit the dessert bar after your meal. Best bread pudding I've had in years! Pricesare very reasonable. Service is friendly as well as attentive. Read more
When in town visiting friends took us to this place and I have never in my life been more disappointed in a dining experience!... Dirty bathrooms, dirty blinds on the windows, if the food on the buffet wasn't cold it was over-cooked and rubbery. Prices werenot posted prominently and we were not informed of the differences in the prices if you ate certain items on the buffet, howeverwait staff watched from the side to see if you ate these 2 items so they could over charge you. Rude and disrespectful pleaseeat elsewhere and save yourself from a miserable experience! Read more
This place was a complete rip-off! They do NOT post the prices prominently in the restaurant NOR do the wait staff let you know... that there are certain items (cold rubbery steak and over cooked crab legs) on the buffet that if you get the price of your mealdoubles from $22 to $45! Our granddaughter had never tasted crab legs and had 2 bites from a leg that my husband did not finishand the waitress rushed over to inform us that she would now be charged for eating crab legs. Ridiculous! 3 adults, a 12 yearand what should have been a free meal for an 8 year old cost $132 ....of course we saved money on the tip because of the rudeway they addressed this issue when we questioned why she would be charged. Never will eat here again! Read more
We hosted a wedding rehearsal dinner at The Putnam Inn last week and I have nothing but positive things to say about the entire... experience. Working with Rhonda was easy. She made sure every detail was taken care of. I was pleased with the set-up,friendly service and value. Overall, I highly recommend. Kudos to the entire team that made our special night a breeze! It wasso nice to just walk in with no worries. Everyone loved it. Read more
Ate at this place on the way home from baseball. The food was great. Our server was pretty great. But unfortunately we were not... told about the price being higher with seafood so I was charged $40 vs. $20 because I had one cluster of crab legs. It wasn?texplained to us and the signage wasn?t clear. We won?t be back. Also, when I asked to speak to someone the poor waitress wassent instead of the owner. When I called to discuss it the manager said she would address that we weren?t told about the prices.It was a joke. I wouldn?t waste your money on a place that scams their customers into paying $40 a meal. Read more
Definitely check this place out on a Friday or Saturday. The seafood buffet is legit and so are the crab legs. The main buffet... is $20 and an additional $20 for the crab legs. The frog legs and shrimp were good as so was the salad bar. Don't pass ondessert because the dessert bar is phenomenal! Read more
I have done dine-in twice and Thanksgiving take-out once. Food was alright each time. I personally find it over rated.