Reviews for Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club in Greendale, WI
A really enjoyable evening at a Milwaukee-area supper club. It’s only about a decade old so it doesn’t have the well-worn... atmosphere of most supper clubs but the staff was fantastic (bartender, hostess and our waitress) and the food and drinks wereexcellent. Good choice of classic old-timey cocktails in addition to the regular fare. The menu was perfect- not too muchselection so you’re overwhelmed- but not too few selections either. We both had steak - perfectly cooked - along w delicioussides. It’s not inexpensive but I would say it’s about what you’d expect for a good meal out. Read more
It’s the perfect mix of upscale fancy mixed with the classic wisconsin supper club. Great classic old fashioned. Friday fish... fry for that supper club vibe with included fried seafood for that fine dining vibe. Best fish fry I’ve ever eaten. Except topay more than a classic supper club which is reflected in the food quality. Read more
We had a great meal with family. It was a perfect birthday celebration. The menu is smaller than it used to be, but everything... we ordered was very good and the service was great. Read more
Food and drinks were absolutely delicious! The Rhubarb fashioned was a surprisingly good twist on a classic (not pictured). The... scallops and steak were cooked to perfection. Part of the clean plate club here. Read more
Amazing service, fantastic food, spectacular atmosphere. This is a great place to have a nice dinner or night out or to... celebrate a special occasion. Kim was an awesome server, thank you Kim! Read more
My wife took me here for the first time on my birthday. Food was absolutely delicious - we both had the chicken marsala. Not to... mention friendly and efficient service and cozy atmosphere! I even got a free dessert for my birthday! Highly recommended. Read more
Quite possibly the best overall meal I've had in Milwaukee. Celebrated 11 years of marriage with my wife and we had a great... experience. Will be back, SOON! We had the 18oz Ribeye, Shrimp Penne ala Vodka and the seared scallops to start. They caughtwind that we were celebrating, so they put the cherry on top with their Lemon tort and ice cream dessert. It was all delicious.Nice touch! Read more
Most amazing steaks ever! I was brought here by my kids for my birthday, didn't know what to expect. I have basic expectations... and this place exceeded them. We had the cheese curds and bacon wrapped fried shrimp as appetizers. I am a really hard judge,especially for beef items and I can say this was worth the drive. Already planning my next experience. Update: Went again with afriend and they did not disappoint! Definitely one of my favorite places. Read more