Reviews for Andy’s Restaurant Greenport New York in Greenport, NY

Stopped in for a late lunch and had a fantastic meal. Service and food were great. We’re looking forward to going back.

We had the pleasure of having our son's wedding welcome party at Andy's. Everything was fantastic! Andy is wonderful to work... with and is very accommodating to your needs. Both the food and atmosphere were perfect for a large gathering. All the guestsenjoyed themselves and it was a perfect way to kickoff a weekend for a wedding celebration. Read more

Been here numerous times in the past, place wasn't busy on a weekday afternoon and thought service would be as previously... visited which would be attentive but new bartender wasn't very friendly or attentive as we sat at bar for bar food anddrinks(definitely a prerequisite for this occupation)and Andy must've had day off, had wings which were sparse, not very big orflavorful and just a letdown from previous trips! Everyone is entitled to a bad day so will give them another shot next time andwill update, but when you're in this business of customer service you must do it right consistently in order to get residualtraffic of face losing it!! Read more

I normally do not complain, but felt I had to. Food was disgusting, and service was bad. Won’t be coming back here, just look... below. My boyfriends chicken was raw!!!! Sweet potato fries looked like a blind man cut them, and if you think you’re gettingclassic fried pickles, don’t be mistaken they will give you whole SPEARS fried. Read more

Ordered takeout chicken fingers and it tasted bland and almost like the fryer grease hasn't been changed. Black burnt speks all... over the chicken. I expected more from this place since I've been there before. Read more

Mediocre food and they will charge you for every single item--pickles, bbq sauce, onion, mustard, etc. etc. I don't appreciate... being nickel and dimed. Hard pass. Read more

The food was delicious. The staff was very attentive and friendly. I had the Ruben, and there was so much corned beef it was... crazy. But so good! My friends had the tomato soup (she loved it!) And the gyro (and he love that also). Fries were perfectlycrispy. There were kids around, so it was a very family friendly place (at lunchtime at least). Read more

A diverse American cuisine reimagined! Local-ingredient-inspired dishes plated beautifully, with a hometown, no-frills feel and... plenty of tvs at the bar to watch the game(s). Wish we could come here more often! Decor (5/5) Food (5/5) Service (4.5/5) Read more