Reviews for Goldberg's Famous Bagels in Greenport, NY
Quite possibly the best everything bagel I have ever had.
One of the best spots for a bagel. Stopped in on a Saturday morning. Bagels were being made fresh and were delicious!! Sesame... bagel with jalapeño cheddar cc was my fav!! My husband got the north fork special and that was also delish!! Read more
I visited while I was staying with my sister. I ordered the hobo on a pumpernickel bagel and was absolutely delightful. It was a... perfect breakfast sandwich. The coffee was hot and very fresh. I wanted to go back and order from their fantastic looking delicase but ran out of time on my trip. Read more
Had the best bagel/flagel sandwich in my life: Famous Northfork Special is truly the best sandwich on Long Island. Friendly and... caring staff make such a difference. They put so much heart into it. Read more
Amazing bagels and the owner is so lovely! We got to talking and he offered me a full bag of Flagels. It made my entire week! I... highly recommend stopping by this place. Read more
The bagels are EXCEPTIONAL! I would highly recommend ordering in advance if you can to pick it up. We ordered a platter for 11... of mixed bagels and various spreads, and it was devoured! The only thing that dropped this review to 4 out of 5 stars was thatat 8:30 AM, we ordered sandwiches for lunch to pick up 2 hours later. The sandwiches had not even begun preparation at 10:30when we arrived and so it was delayed by another hour. That experience wasn't great, and the sandwiches themselves were notgreat either. I think their expertise is bagels, for sure. Read more
Bagels are great! We had a French Toast and an Everything. Perfectly made! Coffee was good and hot. Highly recommend!
Why must such a good place be so tacky in a tourist-driven town like Greenport full of lovely spots like D'Latte and Kate's... Cheese Shop? Inside all you'll see are wall to ceiling 7-11 style stacks of mass-produced chips & Tropicana cartons that couldhave been hidden away out back. Flocks of local high school students are their main source of revenue. Read more