Reviews for Tried & True Alehouse in Greenwood, IN

Food was decent. CBR wrap was quite good. Fries are also good. Mercedes seemed kinda new, but she was very nice and quite... attentive the whole time. All of the servers we talked to during our visit didn't really seem to know the menu, though. Doublereview from table: Turkey mango salad had tinned turkey and a mango sauce rather than actual mangoes. Not worth its price,although the sauce was still good. Read more

They literally charged me 19.50 for 1 basil hayden rye on the rocks!! You can buy an entire bottle for 39.99. The bartender... said she should have told me before I got it. She said it?s top shelf. I always drink top shelf. I?ve had more expensivebourbons and have never been charged such an extremely high amount. That is gauging the customer. I?ve been here several timesand enjoyed it but after this I will not be back. Read more

Wow. amazing experience. Atmosphere was pretty cool. Food was so flavorful and delicious Quick service. . We ordered the... indiana sweet Hoosier hot wings.. oh so good and the burn baby burn burger definitely packs tastes and heat. The nachos with theBuffalo cheese dip was so delicious. Pretzel bites were cooked to perfection. Great service, Awesome food. Great beers. I woulddefinitely recommend this place. Read more

Great sports bar. It was loud. Food was good, hot. Onion rings were hand dipped! Our server, Logan, was very helpful.

This was my first time here and I'll be back! The food was delicious. The scratch made sauces were a huge plus. They have... awesome drink specials too. I can't wait to enjoy their patio. Service was a bit slow but the staff was nice so it was okay inthe end. I'd recommend this place for sure. Read more

Came here for lunch on new year's eve. Somewhat busy, but was seated straight away. Service throughout the visit was prompt... and friendly. Started with the loaded potato nachos.....housemade potato chips, drenched in beer cheese, bacon, and sour cream. They were pretty good, but quite rich. Could use a little acid to cut through it and balance everything....perhaps somepickled jalapenos or pickled onions? Then came the queso chili smothered cheeseburger. Again, quite rich, with not much to cutthrough it. It wasn't bad, and I'm sure it sells well, just based on visual appeal, but I can't imagine anyone ordering it asecond time. There is a burger in there, but you'll never taste it. The beer selection is pretty solid, with several localcraft brews to choose from. I'm looking forward to a return trip and trying something a little more conventional. Read more

I was really impressed; I'm honestly disappointed I've never been before lol. I had the cheeseburger and side salad. The rest of... the table had surf and turf. One had the bleu cheese wedge salad and another had the caprese. All of it was delicious. Thesalads were fresh and the housemade ranch and blue cheese were SO good. I don't normally like balsamic but I even liked that.Service was friendly, quick and they didn't seem short staffed especially compared to other restaurants right now. My picturescertainly don't do the food justice so you'll just have to take my word lol. Highly recommend. Read more

First time here. Better than expected!! Will definitely return. Had beef tips and shrimp. Was awesome!! Great atmosphere,... great music and of course great food. Best pretzel bites we?ve ever had!!! Read more